← All four mayors compared

Mayor of Chicago, 2019–2023

Lori Lightfoot

4

years in office
May 20, 2019 – May 15, 2023

How they took office

Elected in a 2019 runoff, winning all 50 wards

How it ended

Finished third in the 2023 first round

Before City Hall

President of the Chicago Police Board (2015-2018) and chair of the Police Accountability Task Force.

Report card

What changed on Lightfoot’s watch

Twenty-two measures across ten major issues: four for the budget and two for each of the others. Each row compares the last full year before Lightfoot took office with the last full year in office (or the latest data). Green means the measure moved in the better direction, yellow means little change (less than 3%, less than 1 point for rates, or less than 2 points for national test scores, which come from samples), and red means it moved the wrong way. Higher local taxes per resident count as worse. Dollar figures per resident are adjusted for inflation. Mayors share credit and blame with national trends, the state, the weather and the economy, so read this as a record of what happened, not a grade. Where a comparison exists, a line under the numbers shows the U.S. and the other nine of the 10 largest cities or metro areas over the same years.

5Improved5Little change11Worsened1No data for this term
IssueMeasureStart · 2018End · 2022Result
Budget

Credit rating

Moody’s rating on city bonds

At start

Ba1

At end

Baa3

Improved

Up 1 notch

Local taxes per resident

city tax revenue per resident, 2025 dollars

$2,400

$2,510

Worsened

+5%

2018–2022

Budget deficit per resident

projected Corporate Fund gap per resident, 2025 dollars

2020 budget

$380

2023 budget

$50

The gap projected before each budget. Every budget passed closed it.

Improved

−87%

2020–2023

Pension funded ratio

% of promised benefits set aside, four city plans

24.9%

24.2%

Little change

−0.7 points

2018–2022
Housing

New homes permitted

building permits for new homes per year

1,808

1,591

Worsened

−12%

2018–2022

Renters paying 30%+ of income

% of renter households

48.6%

51.5%

Worsened

+2.9 points

2018–2022
Public safety

Murder rate

per 100,000 residents

21.3

26.8

Murders also rose in most large U.S. cities in 2020 and 2021.

U.S. 5.1 → 6.6 (+29%) · other 9 largest cities, median 7.0 → 13.2 (+91%) · Chicago ranked 9th → 9th of 10 (1st = lowest)

Worsened

+26%

Violent crimes

incidents per year

25,327

26,116

Worsened

+3%

2018–2022
Education

Graduation rate

CPS five-year cohort rate

78.2%

84.0%

Improved

+5.8 points

8th-grade math

% proficient, national test (NAEP)

2019

27.2%

15.8%

U.S. public schools 32.9% → 25.5% · large-city average 27.3% → 20.5%

Worsened

−11.4 points

Economy

Unemployment

metro area, annual average

4.1%

4.6%

U.S. 3.9% → 3.7% (−0.2 points) · other 9 largest metros, median 4.0% → 3.6% · Chicago ranked 6th → 9th of 10 (1st = lowest)

Little change

+0.5 points

2018–2022

Jobs in the city

jobs located in the city

1.20M

1.19M

U.S. payroll jobs over the same years: +2%

Little change

0%

2018–2022
Transit

CTA rides

boardings per year

468M

244M

U.S. transit trips over the same years: −37%

Worsened

−48%

2018–2022

CTA service delivered

% of scheduled service run

—

—

No data for this term

Health

Life expectancy

years at birth

2019

78.8

77.2

Earliest data: 2019 Life expectancy also fell nationally during the pandemic.

Worsened

−1.6 years

2019–2022

Overdose deaths

deaths per year

814

1,408

Overdose deaths also rose nationally during the pandemic.

Worsened

+73%

2018–2022
Population

Population

city residents

2.70M

2.68M

U.S. +2% · other 9 largest cities, median −3% (same years)

Little change

−1%

Net migration

people moving in minus out, per year (Cook County)

−50,943

−66,243

Worsened

−15,300 a year

2018–2022
Climate

Days with unhealthy air

air quality index above 100 (metro)

26

15

Improved

−42%

2018–2022

Flooding reports

311 requests per year

2019

4,532

7,404

Earliest data: 2019

Worsened

+63%

2019–2022
Livability

Park access

% of residents within a 10-minute walk

98.0%

98.0%

Little change

0.0 points

2018–2022

Arts and culture venues

per 100,000 residents (metro)

4.8

5.3

Improved

+10%

2018–2022

Years in the column headers apply to every row unless a row shows its own year. Sparklines show every year of data between the two values; each line is scaled to its own range. Rows marked "No data for this term" have no comparable figures for those years. Where a series starts after a mayor took office, the earliest year is used and noted. Unemployment, unhealthy air days and arts venues cover the metro area; net migration covers Cook County. Sources are on each issue page and the Citations page.

Elections

First round, Feb. 26, 2019

Lightfoot 17.54% (97,667, first of 14 candidates), Toni Preckwinkle 16.04% (89,343).

Runoff, Apr. 2, 2019

Lightfoot 73.70% (386,039) def. Toni Preckwinkle 26.30% (137,765). NBC Chicago reports she won all 50 wards.

Budget and finances

  • 2019

    Inherited an $838M deficit and faced a roughly $2B combined gap across the 2020 and 2021 budgets. news.wttw.com

  • 2021 budget (Nov 2020)

    Closed a $1.2B pandemic shortfall partly through $501M in debt refinancing. Included a $93.9M property tax increase (levy passed 28-22, budget 29-21) and tied future levy increases to the lesser of CPI or 5%. blockclubchicago.org

  • 2022 budget (Oct 27, 2021)

    $16.7B, passed 35-15, with a $76.5M levy increase that included a $22.9M automatic inflation-linked hike. Used $385M in federal stimulus to close the 2022 gap. cbsnews.com

  • 2022

    Dropped a proposed $42.7M election-year property tax increase (per WTTW headline). news.wttw.com

  • 2023 budget (Nov 7, 2022)

    $16.4B, passed 32-18, with no property tax or fee increases. Pension contributions exceeded $2.34B, including about $242M above the legal requirement, the first time the city paid more than required. news.wttw.com

  • 2022

    Rating upgrades: Fitch GO BBB- to BBB with a positive outlook (Oct 21, 2022), citing 'improving pension funding practices.' Moody's GO Ba1 to Baa3 (Nov 2022), described by the city as its first Moody's investment-grade upgrade in 12 years. chicago.gov

Timeline

Decisions the mayor made or backed Events during the term

  1. 2019 Action

    Hours after being sworn in, signed an executive order ending departments' deference to aldermanic prerogative ('aldermen will no longer have a veto'). WTTW notes the zoning code was left untouched. WTTW

  2. 2019 Action

    Launched INVEST South/West, a $750M city commitment for 10 South and West Side community areas. The city reported more than $2.2B in public and private commitments by Nov 2022. City of Chicago press release

  3. 2019-2023 Action

    Ethics changes expanded the inspector general's authority, raised fines from $2,000 to $20,000 and barred aldermen from working as property tax attorneys. WTTW

  4. 2019-2023 Action

    Pushed through a plan to raise the city minimum wage to $15 an hour. NBC Chicago

  5. 2019 Event

    Chicago Teachers Union strike lasted 11 school days, which a WTTW caption calls the longest teachers strike in more than three decades. It ended Oct 31, 2019 with a five-year contract. WTTW

  6. 2019-2021 Event

    Anjanette Young wrong-home police raid (2019) and its handling: Lightfoot said she learned of it from the media, but emails showed she was briefed in Nov 2019. The 2021 police killings of Adam Toledo and Anthony Alvarez also drew wide condemnation. WTTW

  7. 2020 Event

    COVID-19: on Mar 26, 2020 Lightfoot closed the lakefront, Millennium Park, the Riverwalk and the 606 to enforce the state stay-at-home order. City of Chicago press release

  8. 2020 Event

    Unrest after George Floyd's killing (late May-June) was followed by downtown looting Aug 9-10, 2020, with more than 100 arrests. The city raised bridges and restricted transit, and Lightfoot called it 'abject criminal behavior.' A WTTW analysis says an inspector general probe found the response was botched. NPR; WTTW

  9. 2021 Action

    City Council approved 36-13 a civilian police oversight ordinance creating a seven-member commission and 22 elected district councils, with the first elections in 2023. WBEZ

  10. 2021 Action

    City Council approved 40-8 an eight-year FOP police contract with 20% raises, including about $377.6M in back pay. Chicago Sun-Times

  11. 2021 Action

    The 2022 budget ($16.7B, passed 35-15) included a $31.5M guaranteed income pilot giving $500 monthly checks to 5,000 families, and a $1.9B Chicago Recovery Plan funded mostly by federal relief. CBS Chicago

  12. 2021 Event

    Chicago recorded 797 homicides in 2021 per CPD, the most since 1996, along with 3,561 shooting incidents. (A 2025 Fox 32 CPD series lists 804 for 2021, so sources conflict.) NBC Chicago

  13. 2022 Action

    City Council approved 41-7 Lightfoot's pick of Bally's $1.73B River West casino. Bally's pays a $40M upfront fee, and the casino is expected to send about $200M to police and fire pensions. WTTW

  14. 2022 Event

    CTU voted to refuse in-person work over COVID safety in January 2022, and CPS canceled classes for at least four straight school days. WTTW's legacy piece describes it as a five-day lockout. WTTW

How people judge the record

We don’t grade mayors. Here is what named supporters and critics have said, each linked to the source.

What supporters say

She left the city on firm financial footing, citing pension progress (nearly $1B more paid into four pension funds from 2019 to 2023). She said, 'I feel very comfortable with the way in which we governed.'

Lori Lightfoot · WTTW

She invested in 'communities that have been neglected for decades,' expanded mental health services and made 'record investments' in schools. She also cited a 14% drop in homicides and a 20% drop in shootings year over year.

Lori Lightfoot · NBC Chicago

Moody's upgraded Chicago to investment grade (Ba1 to Baa3) in Nov 2022, saying the city 'substantially increased its pension contributions' and reduced a large structural deficit.

Moody's (as quoted in a City of Chicago release) · City of Chicago

The civilian oversight ordinance was 'a strong, transformative and robust ordinance' and a step toward rebuilding community-police trust.

Ald. Carlos Ramirez-Rosa; Lightfoot · WBEZ

What critics say

She fell short on reform and transparency, and on some measures conditions were worse than under Emanuel.

Joseph Ferguson, former Inspector General · WTTW

She was 'unfit to lead' the city.

CTU President Stacy Davis Gates · WTTW

Critics blamed her for rising violent crime. Paul Vallas said she wasn't tough enough on crime, and Brandon Johnson promised a broader public safety approach.

2023 mayoral opponents · WTTW; NBC Chicago

Progressive groups objected to using $281.5M in federal relief for police salaries. Alders said South and West Side corridors were left exposed during the 2020 unrest. Ald. Raymond Lopez called the 2022 budget a '$16 billion spending spree.'

Council Progressive Caucus; alders; Ald. Raymond Lopez · WTTW; CBS Chicago

Public opinion polls

Independent and media polls only; polls paid for by advocacy groups or campaigns are left out.

Jan 31-Feb 3, 2023Mason-Dixon for WBEZ/Sun-Times/Telemundo/NBC5 (625 likely voters, ±4)61% disapproved of her job performance; 22% favorable, 54% unfavorable WBEZ ↗
Sources and method

City figures: CPD annual reports and CompStat (murders), U.S. Census Bureau estimates (population), CTA ridership data on the City data portal, CPS budget appendices (enrollment), BLS via FRED (metro unemployment), City Clerk appropriation ordinances and the City data portal (Corporate Fund), and Moody’s actions reported by the Bond Buyer, the Civic Federation and the City. Murder rates are calculated from CPD counts and Census population.