Explainer · School closures
The facts, the trends, how other big cities compare, and the strongest case on each side, as Chicago’s first elected school board prepares to decide.
304,687
CPS students this fall
Down from about 439,000 at the 2002–03 peak
140+
Schools less than half full
Of roughly 500 district-run schools
50
Schools Chicago closed in 2013
About 12,000 students moved; 88% were Black
Jan. 15
Elected school board takes office
2027; closures are on hold through 2026–27
In 30 seconds
CPS has about 134,000 fewer students than at its peak and lost 11,500 in the past year alone.
More than 140 schools are less than half full. The emptiest cost several times more per student.
A board moratorium blocks closing district-run schools through 2026–27. The new elected board decides what’s next.
Supporters cite money and what small schools can offer. Opponents cite the harm from 2013’s mass closings.
As of Nov. 17, 2026. Election results are preliminary as reported Nov. 5.
The numbers
This fall CPS counted 304,687 students. The district points to falling birth rates, families moving to the suburbs and fewer immigrant families.
CPS students on the 20th day of school, selected years. 2002 and 2012 are rounded.
Each square is one school, by the district’s space formula. CPS says the formula may overstate open space.
Sources: Chalkbeat, school board candidates debate closures (Oct. 28, 2026) ↗ · Chalkbeat and ProPublica, small schools and high costs (June 2025) ↗ · Illinois Policy Institute, CPS underused buildings (Aug. 2026) ↗
Why the cost of empty space matters now.
$732M
Budget gap CPS closed to pass its 2027 budget
$150M
State money the budget counts on that lawmakers haven’t approved
$3.1B
Critical repairs needed; $400M of it in the emptiest buildings
86 yrs
Average age of CPS’s 799 buildings
On the map
Enrollment losses, small schools and the 2013 closings all cluster on the West and South Sides.
Change in students at CPS schools in each community area, 2016–17 to 2024–25 (by school location, so openings and moves shift counts). Red dots: the 48 district-run schools that closed in 2013.
The 91 district-run schools with fewer than 250 students in 2024–25 (dark dots, sized by enrollment). Gray dots are the other 425.
Community areas with the most small schools.
−35%
Steepest drop: East Garfield Park
Students at CPS schools there, 2016–17 to 2024–25
43 of 67
Schools less than half full in board districts 5a and 5b
Versus 1 of 15 underused in district 4b
About 6
Of 20 board districts hold most of the underused schools
So any plan lands on a few neighborhoods
Enrollment is from the CPS school profiles for 2016–17 and 2024–25 on the City of Chicago data portal, summed by the community area each school sits in, including charter schools. The 2013 closings are district-run schools on CPS’s 2012–13 school location list that are missing from the 2013–14 list; the official count was 49 elementary schools and one high school program. Small schools are district-run schools in the 2024–25 profiles. Community area boundaries are from the city. Board-district figures are from Chalkbeat. CPS school profiles 2024–25 ↗ · CPS school profiles 2016–17 ↗ · CPS school locations 2012–13 ↗ · CPS school locations 2013–14 ↗ · Community area boundaries ↗ · Chalkbeat, school board candidates debate closures (Oct. 28, 2026) ↗
Inside a small school
Small schools cost more per student, offer fewer classes and teams, and their students are more likely to be chronically truant.
Case study · Douglass Academy High School, Austin
28 students
In a building made for 1,008
27 staff
6 regular and 6 special education teachers, a counselor, a college coach, a conflict resolution specialist, a restorative justice coordinator, an assistant principal and a principal, among others
$93,000
Spent per student
About 5 times the district average
$18,700
Average per student in well-used CPS buildings
Sources: ProPublica, Chicago’s underenrolled schools ↗ · Chalkbeat and ProPublica, small schools and high costs (June 2025) ↗ · Illinois Policy Institute, CPS underused buildings (Aug. 2026) ↗
Spending per student, 2024–25. At some small schools, costs are double or triple the district average.
Typical well-used CPS building
DuSable campus (two small schools)
Williams Prep (about 70 students)
Douglass Academy (28 students)
Sources: Chalkbeat and ProPublica, small schools and high costs (June 2025) ↗ · ProPublica, Chicago’s underenrolled schools ↗
Examples from Chalkbeat and ProPublica’s reporting on Bronzeville and the West Side.
Sources: ProPublica, Chicago’s underenrolled schools ↗ · Chalkbeat and ProPublica, small schools and high costs (June 2025) ↗
Since 2024, CPS guarantees every school a minimum package regardless of enrollment.
*For 2026–27, CPS stopped funding assistant principals at schools with fewer than 250 students. More than 130 small schools were affected; most kept the position anyway. CPS added nearly 10,000 positions since 2019 while enrollment fell by 45,000.
What small schools can do well
Lots of adult attention and small classes. Williams Prep, with about 70 students, graduated 93% of its class of 14. Researcher Bruce Fuller notes small schools can do well, but schools that shrank through decline are a different story.
Sources: ProPublica, Chicago’s underenrolled schools ↗ · Chalkbeat and ProPublica, small schools and high costs (June 2025) ↗
Median results for district-run high schools grouped by enrollment. Smaller high schools have far more chronic truancy and lower graduation and college enrollment.
Share of students missing 5% or more of school days without a valid excuse. Lower is better.
Under 250 students (17 schools)
250–499 students (19 schools)
500–999 students (19 schools)
1,000+ students (31 schools)
Share of students graduating within four years. Higher is better.
Under 250 students (15 schools)
250–499 students (20 schools)
500–999 students (19 schools)
1,000+ students (31 schools)
Share of graduates enrolling in college. Higher is better.
Under 250 students (16 schools)
250–499 students (20 schools)
500–999 students (18 schools)
1,000+ students (31 schools)
We matched the 91 district-run high schools (excluding Options alternative schools) in CPS’s 2024–25 school profiles to the most recent CPS progress reports, mostly 2023–24 results, and grouped them by 2024–25 enrollment. Figures are medians; not every school reports every measure. Illinois defines a chronic truant as a student absent without valid cause for 5% or more of the past 180 school days. City of Chicago data portal, CPS School Progress Reports SY2425 ↗ · City of Chicago data portal, CPS School Profile Information SY2425 ↗ · Illinois School Code, 105 ILCS 5/26-2a (truancy definitions) ↗ · ProPublica, Chicago’s underenrolled schools ↗
How we got here
2002–03 · Enrollment
Enrollment peaks
About 439,000 students.
Source: Chicago Sun-Times, CPS enrollment drops again (Sept. 24, 2026) ↗
2002–2017 · Closings
About 200 schools closed or overhauled
Many for low performance, leaving dozens of vacant buildings.
May 2013 · Closings
50 schools closed in one vote
Largest mass closing in U.S. history. Nearly 12,000 students moved; CPS cited empty seats and a $1B deficit.
Sources: Education Week, 2018 Consortium closure study ↗ · Education Week, Chicago school closures (May 2013) ↗
2018 · Closings
Englewood consolidation
Four shrinking high schools phased out; Englewood STEM High opened in 2019.
2021 · Pause
State law pauses closings
The elected-board law bars CPS closings until January 2025.
Sept. 2024 · Pause
Board moratorium
No closing district-run schools through 2026–27. Charter schools are not covered.
Sources: WTTW, board votes to prohibit closures until 2027 (Sept. 2024) ↗ · Chicago Board of Education, moratorium resolution 24-0926-RS1 ↗
2024 · Pause
State extension stalls
Passes the House 92–8; never called in the Senate.
Source: Chicago Tribune via Lewiston Tribune, Senate shelves moratorium extension (May 2024) ↗
2025–26 · Closings
Charter closures and building sales
Two Acero and two Aspira charter schools close; CPS puts 20 old buildings up for sale.
Sources: Chalkbeat, board saves 5 of 7 Acero charter schools (Feb. 2025) ↗ · ABC7 Chicago, CPS shuts two Aspira charter schools (Feb. 2026) ↗ · Chalkbeat, CPS puts 20 old school properties up for sale (May 2025) ↗
Sept. 2026 · Enrollment
304,687 students
Down 11,500 in one year. CEO Macquline King launches a community-led “reimagining” effort.
Sources: Chicago Public Schools, 2026-27 20th-day enrollment ↗ · Chalkbeat, school board candidates debate closures (Oct. 28, 2026) ↗
Nov. 3, 2026 · Governance
All 21 board seats elected
Chicago’s first fully elected school board.
Source: Chalkbeat, takeaways on the first elected board (Nov. 5, 2026) ↗
Jan. 15, 2027 · Governance
Elected board takes office
Decides whether to extend the moratorium or plan school changes.
Source: FOX 32, Biggs declares victory ↗
Last time
~12,000
Students moved to new schools
88%
Of displaced students were Black
Versus 43% of the district
$25M
Yearly labor savings
Officials projected $43M
26 of 46
Buildings still not in use in 2023
The 46 buildings emptied by the 2013 closings, as of May 2023. Since late 2025 CPS has lined up buyers for several, for housing, an athletic center and a community center.
Sources: Chicago Sun-Times and WBEZ, what became of the closed buildings (May 2023) ↗ · Chalkbeat, buyers for three vacant schools (Dec. 2025) ↗ · Chicago Tribune via AOL, board approves buyers for two closed buildings (2026) ↗
| Outcome | Result | What researchers and reporters found |
|---|---|---|
| Math scores | Worse | Dropped in the year closings were announced and stayed lower for the four years studied. Source: UChicago Consortium, school closings lessons for district leaders (June 2026) ↗ |
| Reading scores | Mixed | Smaller drop that faded. Source: UChicago Consortium, school closings lessons for district leaders (June 2026) ↗ |
| Grades, attendance, suspensions | Little change | Little or no effect in Chicago studies; graduation no better than at similar schools that stayed open. Sources: UChicago Consortium, school closings lessons for district leaders (June 2026) ↗ · Chicago Sun-Times and WBEZ, did the city keep its promises? (2023) ↗ |
| Receiving schools | Worse | Staff felt unprepared; many displaced students didn’t feel welcome; 21% of students didn’t return the next fall. |
| Savings | Less than promised | About $25M a year in labor savings, $18M less than projected; buildings hard to sell. Sources: WBEZ via NPR, 10 years after the closings (June 2023) ↗ · The 74, Chicago closures a cautionary tale ↗ · Chalkbeat, CPS puts 20 old school properties up for sale (May 2025) ↗ |
| Neighborhood population | Worse | Black neighborhoods with a closure lost people about 3x as fast as others, though they were already shrinking. Source: Chicago Sun-Times and WBEZ, did the city keep its promises? (2023) ↗ |
| Violence nearby | Mixed | A 2026 study found shootings up about 10% near closed schools left empty, none where reused; a 2020 study found the reverse. Sources: Chicago Sun-Times, shootings rose near closed schools that sat empty (June 2026) ↗ · UChicago and Johns Hopkins study release (Social Science & Medicine, 2026) ↗ · Noli Brazil, school closures and crime, Sociological Science (2020) ↗ |
Displaced students were also more likely to be low-income or in special education, and deep distrust of CPS lingers, especially in Black neighborhoods.
Sources: Education Week, Chicago school closures (May 2013) ↗ · Chicago Tribune via inkl, study on the aftermath of the 2013 closings ↗ · Chalkbeat and ProPublica, small schools and high costs (June 2025) ↗
The debate
Common ground
Chicago has far more space than students, and 2013’s top-down approach should not be repeated.
“Our footprint is too large.”
Pedro Martinez, former CPS CEO, 2025
Source: Chalkbeat and ProPublica, small schools and high costs (June 2025) ↗
“We cannot repeat a top-down mass closure experience.”
Jessica Biggs, incoming board president, during the campaign
Source: WBEZ, board president candidates on closures (Sept. 17, 2026) ↗
What the research says
In eight of nine studies reviewed by Chalkbeat, students who moved to higher-performing schools did better.
Sources: Chalkbeat, a decade of research on school closures (2019) ↗ · Research for Action, revisiting research on school closings (2024) ↗
Sources: Chad Aldeman, The 74, delaying closures makes things worse ↗ · UChicago Consortium, school closings lessons for district leaders (June 2026) ↗
UChicago Consortium
Math losses lasting four years; welcoming schools strained; little change in grades or attendance.
Sources: UChicago Consortium, school closings lessons for district leaders (June 2026) ↗ · Education Week, 2018 Consortium closure study ↗
Quentin Brummet, 2014
No lasting harm on average; students from the weakest schools gained, receiving schools paid a price.
Source: Quentin Brummet, school closings in Michigan, Journal of Public Economics (2014) ↗
Kemple; Bifulco and Schwegman
Later students went to better schools and graduated more; displaced low achievers were hurt.
Sources: NPR, research on New York City high school closures ↗ · Bifulco and Schwegman, accountability-driven closure in New York City (2018) ↗
Stanford, Getting Down to Facts
Closures cut spending and revenue per student by about the same amount, about $440 each.
Source: American School & University, Stanford Getting Down to Facts study (May 2026) ↗
National studies also link closures to lower graduation, college attendance and lifetime earnings.
Source: UChicago Consortium, school closings lessons for district leaders (June 2026) ↗
Other cities
Most of the largest districts are closing or consolidating schools again. Chicago is the main exception.
Status of school closures in each city’s main school district (Phoenix has many districts).
666 → 1,000+
Public schools closed nationally per year
From 2021–22, the fewest in 20+ years, to 2025–26, the fourth straight rise (preliminary federal data)
Schools approved for closure or consolidation.
Chicago, 2013
Fort Worth ISD, 2025 (through 2029)
Philadelphia, 2026 (from 2027–28)
San Antonio ISD, 2023
Houston ISD, 2026
Chicago, 2024–27
Pressure: 304,687 students, about 134,000 below the 2002–03 peak.
Decision: No district-run closings since 2018; moratorium through 2026–27. Charter schools have closed.
Sources: Chicago Public Schools, 2026-27 20th-day enrollment ↗ · Chicago Board of Education, moratorium resolution 24-0926-RS1 ↗ · ABC7 Chicago, CPS shuts two Aspira charter schools (Feb. 2026) ↗
Pressure: About 790,000 students, down about 170,000 in a decade; 224 schools with 200 or fewer.
Decision: Merging small schools; proposed closing three Harlem schools in fall 2026.
Sources: Chalkbeat New York, Harlem closure proposal (Oct. 2026) ↗ · Chalkbeat New York, two tiny Harlem schools proposed for closure (Nov. 2026) ↗
Pressure: About 374,000 students, down from 700,000+ in the early 2000s.
Decision: Community meetings under way; budget counts on $30M a year from consolidation by 2028–29.
Sources: LAist, LAUSD begins the case for closures (2026) ↗ · LAist, LAUSD budget and closure conversations (Sept. 2026) ↗
Pressure: Lost about 7,900 students in 2025–26; about 25% of campuses under half full.
Decision: State-appointed board voted 9–0 in Feb. 2026 to close or consolidate 12 campuses.
Sources: KPRC, Houston ISD board votes to close 12 campuses (Feb. 2026) ↗ · Axios Houston, HISD enrollment and capacity ↗
Pressure: Served by about 30 districts, many losing students.
Decision: Phoenix Elementary closed two schools in 2025; Roosevelt Elementary closed five.
Pressure: Facing a $300 million budget gap.
Decision: Board voted 6–3 in Apr. 2026 to close 17 schools starting 2027–28 and modernize 169.
Sources: WHYY, 17 Philadelphia schools set to close (May 2026) ↗ · PhillyVoice, board approves plan to close 17 schools (Apr. 30, 2026) ↗
Pressure: San Antonio ISD lost students for years, partly to charters.
Decision: Closed 15 schools in 2024 after a 5–2 vote; about 10% of affected students left the district.
Source: Texas Public Radio, 10% of affected SAISD students leaving (2024) ↗
Pressure: Lost about 16,000 students (12%) in a decade; about half its schools under 70% of capacity.
Decision: Removing middle grades from four K–8 schools; no full closures announced.
Sources: Voice of San Diego, enrollment decline (Feb. 2026) ↗ · Voice of San Diego, San Diego Unified underused schools (2025) ↗ · KPBS, San Diego Unified phases out some K-8 middle grades ↗
Pressure: Dallas ISD down about 20,000 students since 2014.
Decision: Weighing six closures for 2027–28 amid a $100M+ shortfall.
Sources: FOX 4, Dallas ISD considers closing six campuses ↗ · Dallas Observer, North Texas school closures ↗
Pressure: Down 15% since 2019–20; $1.2B in needed repairs.
Decision: Closing 18 schools through 2029 under a 2025 plan.
Sources: KERA, Fort Worth ISD closures begin (Jan. 2026) ↗ · Fort Worth Star-Telegram via Yahoo, FWISD approves 18 closures ↗
Who decides
Oct. 1
Guidelines
CEO publishes draft criteria; 21 days of public comment.
Dec. 1
Proposals
Any closure for the end of the school year must be announced.
Winter
Hearings
Community meetings and hearings before an independent officer.
Spring
Board vote
The board makes the final decision.
Summer
Takes effect
Schools close at the end of the school year.
Earliest closings under the normal process: after the 2027–28 school year, because the new board takes office after the Dec. 1, 2026 deadline. It could also extend the moratorium.
Sources: Illinois School Code, 105 ILCS 5/34-230 ↗ · CPS, final guidelines for school actions, 2025-26 ↗ · Chicago Board of Education, moratorium resolution 24-0926-RS1 ↗
Preliminary board makeup as reported Nov. 5, 2026; four races were still too close to call.
11 Backed by school-choice groups, including President Jessica Biggs
9 Endorsed by the Chicago Teachers Union (if leads hold)
1 Backed by SEIU but not the CTU
Only 6 presumed winners said they support closing schools.
Sources: Chalkbeat, takeaways on the first elected board (Nov. 5, 2026) ↗ · FOX 32, Biggs declares victory ↗
Sources: WBEZ, board president candidates on closures (Sept. 17, 2026) ↗ · Chalkbeat, school board candidates debate closures (Oct. 28, 2026) ↗
Ideas on the table
Upside: Time to build trust and a community plan before any closure.
Concern: Costs keep rising and students stay in very small schools; waiting can force abrupt closings later.
Sources: Chalkbeat, school board candidates debate closures (Oct. 28, 2026) ↗ · Chad Aldeman, The 74, delaying closures makes things worse ↗
Upside: High schools at 20% of capacity can’t offer a full program; Englewood STEM replaced four.
Concern: Safety and travel concerns; the 2018 Englewood plan drew protests.
Sources: WBEZ, board president candidates on closures (Sept. 17, 2026) ↗ · WTTW, Englewood high schools phased out (2018) ↗
Upside: King’s “reimagining” effort; Philadelphia and Fort Worth used long-range facilities plans.
Concern: Can take years, and the board still has the final say.
Sources: Chalkbeat, school board candidates debate closures (Oct. 28, 2026) ↗ · WHYY, 17 Philadelphia schools set to close (May 2026) ↗ · KERA, Fort Worth ISD closures begin (Jan. 2026) ↗
Upside: Clinics, food pantries and family services use idle rooms and draw families.
Concern: 17 of 20 Sustainable Community Schools, given $500K a year each, lost students faster than the district.
Sources: Chalkbeat, school board candidates debate closures (Oct. 28, 2026) ↗ · Chalkbeat and ProPublica, small schools and high costs (June 2025) ↗
Upside: At least $40M is turning three North Lawndale schools into STEAM academies.
Concern: A large investment for three schools, and too early to know if it works.
Source: Chalkbeat and ProPublica, three schools get STEAM makeovers (Sept. 2025) ↗
Upside: Ends upkeep costs; reuse avoided the rise in shootings.
Concern: Buildings have been hard to sell, and it doesn’t help half-empty schools still open.
Sources: Chalkbeat, CPS puts 20 old school properties up for sale (May 2025) ↗ · Chalkbeat, buyers for three vacant schools (Dec. 2025) ↗ · Chicago Sun-Times, shootings rose near closed schools that sat empty (June 2026) ↗
Upside: Two schools in one building cut overhead; Philadelphia plans six co-locations.
Concern: Saves less than closing; merging communities can create conflict.
Sources: WHYY, 17 Philadelphia schools set to close (May 2026) ↗ · UChicago Consortium, school closings lessons for district leaders (June 2026) ↗
Ask the candidates
Should the moratorium be extended past 2026–27? For how long, and what happens meanwhile?
At what enrollment or cost per student would you consider merging a school?
How would you make sure displaced students land in stronger schools, and who tracks it?
What should happen to empty buildings, and who pays to keep them up until then?
Should high schools and elementary schools be handled differently?
How would affected neighborhoods be involved, and who has the final say?
Questions
Not a district-run school. The moratorium covers closings, consolidations, phase-outs and boundary changes at district-run schools through 2026–27. Charter and contract schools aren’t covered, which is why two Aspira charter high schools closed midyear in 2026.
CPS sets an ideal enrollment for each building (77% of maximum capacity for elementary schools, 80% for high schools) and calls a school underutilized below 70% of that ideal, according to the Illinois Policy Institute’s reading of the formula. CPS says the formula may overstate open space.
Fewer births, families moving to the suburbs and slower immigration. School choice has also drawn students from many neighborhood schools, a trend the previous board said it wanted to reverse.
Not on its own. The gap runs to hundreds of millions of dollars a year, and studies in Chicago and California suggest closures save far less. Supporters see consolidation as one part of a longer-term fix along with state funding and pensions.
Sources
Enrollment figures are CPS 20th-day counts and differ slightly from the federal counts on the CPS data page. Figures attributed to the Illinois Policy Institute come from a free-market policy group working from CPS data. Board election results were preliminary when reported.
More: All explainers · Education · Chicago Public Schools by the numbers · Education: who’s accountable · Segregation