← All four mayors compared

Mayor of Chicago, 1989–2011

Richard M. Daley

22

years in office
Apr. 24, 1989 – May 16, 2011

How they took office

Won a 1989 special election to finish Washington’s term, then five full terms

How it ended

Did not seek a seventh term

Before City Hall

Cook County State's Attorney, 1981-1989. Before that he was an Illinois state senator and a delegate to the 1970 Illinois Constitutional Convention

Report card

What changed on Daley’s watch

Twenty-two measures across ten major issues: four for the budget and two for each of the others. Each row compares the last full year before Daley took office with the last full year in office (or the latest data). Green means the measure moved in the better direction, yellow means little change (less than 3%, less than 1 point for rates, or less than 2 points for national test scores, which come from samples), and red means it moved the wrong way. Higher local taxes per resident count as worse. Dollar figures per resident are adjusted for inflation. Mayors share credit and blame with national trends, the state, the weather and the economy, so read this as a record of what happened, not a grade. Where a comparison exists, a line under the numbers shows the U.S. and the other nine of the 10 largest cities or metro areas over the same years.

7Improved1Little change7Worsened7No data for this term
IssueMeasureStart · 1990End · 2010Result
Budget

Credit rating

Moody’s rating on city bonds

1992

A

At end

Aa3

Earliest rating in our sources

Improved

Upgraded

Local taxes per resident

city tax revenue per resident, 2025 dollars

1994

$1,459

$1,727

City reports online start in 1994.

Worsened

+18%

1994–2010

Budget deficit per resident

projected Corporate Fund gap per resident, 2025 dollars

2008 budget

$115

2011 budget

$346

The gap projected before each budget. Every budget passed closed it.

Worsened

+201%

2008–2011

Pension funded ratio

% of promised benefits set aside, four city plans

2001

83.6%

46.6%

Earliest data: 2001

Worsened

−37.0 points

2001–2010
Housing

New homes permitted

building permits for new homes per year

2006

3,380

747

Earliest data: 2006

Worsened

−78%

2006–2010

Renters paying 30%+ of income

% of renter households

—

—

No data for this term

Public safety

Murder rate

per 100,000 residents

30.6

16.2

Earliest data: 1990

U.S. 9.4 → 4.8 (−49%) · other 9 largest cities, median 29.0 → 8.0 (−72%) · Chicago ranked 6th → 9th of 10 (1st = lowest)

Improved

−47%

Violent crimes

incidents per year

2006

35,103

30,307

Earliest data: 2006

Improved

−14%

2006–2010
Education

Graduation rate

CPS five-year cohort rate

1999

47.0%

55.8%

Earliest data: 1999

Improved

+8.8 points

8th-grade math

% proficient, national test (NAEP)

2003

9.0%

2009

15.5%

Earliest data: 2003

U.S. public schools 27.3% → 32.5% · large-city average 16.4% → 23.7%

Improved

+6.5 points

Economy

Unemployment

metro area, annual average

6.4%

10.5%

Earliest data: 1990

U.S. 5.6% → 9.6% (+4.0 points) · other 9 largest metros, median 5.1% → 9.1% · Chicago ranked 9th → 8th of 10 (1st = lowest)

Worsened

+4.1 points

2005–2010

Jobs in the city

jobs located in the city

2005

1.07M

1.01M

Earliest data: 2005

U.S. payroll jobs over the same years: −3%

Worsened

−5%

2005–2010
Transit

CTA rides

boardings per year

1988

605M

517M

U.S. transit trips, 2000–2010 (earliest national data): +7%; CTA +8% over the same years

Worsened

−15%

2005–2010

CTA service delivered

% of scheduled service run

—

—

No data for this term

Health

Life expectancy

years at birth

70.5

77.8

Earliest data: 1990

Improved

+7.3 years

1990–2010

Overdose deaths

deaths per year

—

—

No data for this term

Population

Population

city residents

2.78M

2.70M

Earliest data: 1990

U.S. +24% · other 9 largest cities, median +19% (same years)

Little change

−3%

1990–2010

Net migration

people moving in minus out, per year (Cook County)

—

—

No data for this term

Climate

Days with unhealthy air

air quality index above 100 (metro)

2005

74

35

Earliest data: 2005

Improved

−53%

2005–2010

Flooding reports

311 requests per year

—

—

No data for this term

Livability

Park access

% of residents within a 10-minute walk

—

—

No data for this term

Arts and culture venues

per 100,000 residents (metro)

—

—

No data for this term

Years in the column headers apply to every row unless a row shows its own year. Sparklines show every year of data between the two values; each line is scaled to its own range. Rows marked "No data for this term" have no comparable figures for those years. Where a series starts after a mayor took office, the earliest year is used and noted. Unemployment, unhealthy air days and arts venues cover the metro area; net migration covers Cook County. Sources are on each issue page and the Citations page.

Elections

Feb. 28, 1989 (primary)

Daley 55.63%, Mayor Eugene Sawyer 43.98%

April 1989 (special general)

Daley 55.43%, Timothy Evans (Harold Washington Party) 41.11%, Edward Vrdolyak (R) 3.46%

Apr. 2, 1991

Daley 70.64%, R. Eugene Pincham 25.13%

1995

Daley 60.09%, Roland Burris (Independent) 36.28%

1999

Daley 71.89%, Bobby Rush 28.11%

Feb. 25, 2003

Daley 78.46%, Paul Jakes Jr. 14.02%

Feb. 27, 2007

Daley 71.05%, Dorothy Brown 20.12%

Budget and finances

  • 1989

    Faced a $120M budget deficit on taking office. americanbanker.com

  • 1991

    FY1991 budget: $3.18B. GO ratings: S&P A-, Moody's A. GO debt: $771M (end of 1990). americanbanker.com

  • 1992

    FY1993 budget ($1.76B operating, $3.33B all funds) closed an $89M gap. It included a $28.7M property tax increase and a new soft-drink tax. americanbanker.com

  • 1991-2010

    The Reader's Mick Dumke found the budget grew from about $3.3B (1991) to a proposed $6.1B, contradicting Daley's claim of $2.5B in cuts. nbcchicago.com

  • 2000-2009

    Direct tax-supported debt rose 122% to $6.9B (Civic Federation). Net direct debt per capita was $2,468 in 2009. bondbuyer.com

  • 2010-2011

    FY2011 budget: $6.2B with a $654.8M shortfall. More than 80% of the $2.98B in Skyway and meter lease money would be spent by the end of FY2011. Unfunded pensions were $12.4B (FY2009). civicfed.org

  • 2011

    Fitch cut the city to AA-, S&P to A+ and Moody's to Aa3. The pension funds held $14.6B unfunded and were 43% funded. The $1.15B meter reserve was nearly drained. bondbuyer.com

  • 2000s

    The state raised pension benefits in the late 1990s without the city raising contributions. By 2011 funding was about half of 2000 levels, and budgets passed 50-0 from 2000 to 2004. effectivegov.uchicago.edu

Timeline

Decisions the mayor made or backed Events during the term

  1. 1989-2011 Action

    Other programs: the 311 line, the CAPS community policing program, Tax Increment Financing, Blue Bag recycling, the Navy Pier revitalization and green roofs, including the City Hall rooftop garden (2000). UIC Library; NBC Chicago

  2. 1992 Event

    Loop Flood: about 250M gallons of water entered freight tunnels and basements, and eight city officials were asked to resign or retire. CBS Chicago

  3. 1995 Action

    Chicago Public Schools came under direct mayoral control, with an appointed board and a CEO. Paul Vallas was the first CEO. CBS Chicago

  4. 1995 Event

    A July heat wave was blamed for 739 deaths. Critics faulted City Hall for not declaring an emergency, and the city then created an early-warning system. CBS Chicago

  5. 1996 Event

    Chicago hosted the Democratic National Convention, its first since 1968. CBS Chicago

  6. 1999-2000 Action

    Plan for Transformation: the CHA pledged to build or rehabilitate 25,000 units and planned to demolish 18,000 apartments, mainly high-rises such as Cabrini-Green and Robert Taylor. Sources differ on timing: announced 1999, begun 2000. Chicago Sun-Times/BGA

  7. 2003 Action

    Crews cut X's into the Meigs Field runway overnight, citing terrorism concerns. The FAA fined the city $33,000, and the site became a 91-acre park on Northerly Island. CBS Chicago; City Journal

  8. 2004 Action

    Millennium Park opened four years late and over budget. UIC puts the cost at about $500M. CBS Chicago; UIC Library

  9. 2004-2006 Event

    Hired Truck Program scandal and a federal patronage investigation. Patronage chief Robert Sorich was convicted, and a federal judge ordered a monitor over city hiring. NBC Chicago

  10. 2005 Action

    The Chicago Skyway was leased for 99 years for $1.8B. Bond Buyer

  11. 2006 Action

    Vetoed a 'big box' living wage ordinance. UIC Library

  12. 2008 Action

    Parking meters were leased for 75 years for $1.157B to a Morgan Stanley-backed firm. Daley defended it as a way to avoid a tax increase. The Inspector General later said the council approved it two days after announcement with no meaningful review. CBS Chicago; WBEZ

  13. 2009 Event

    Chicago's 2016 Olympic bid was eliminated in the first round in Copenhagen. CBS Chicago

  14. 2010 Event

    The U.S. Supreme Court struck down Chicago's handgun law in McDonald v. Chicago. UIC Library

How people judge the record

We don’t grade mayors. Here is what named supporters and critics have said, each linked to the source.

What supporters say

He remade the lakefront and neighborhoods. Millennium Park is a 'world-class urban treasure,' and neighborhood investments such as trees, bike lanes and CTA rehab helped drive Chicago's revival.

Aaron M. Renn, Manhattan Institute (City Journal, 2017) · City Journal

He turned Chicago into a tourist destination, modernized the CTA, pushed green policy and fostered prosperity. He 'should be considered one of Chicago's greatest mayors.'

NBC Chicago Ward Room column (2010) · NBC Chicago

He required homework and ended social promotion after taking over the schools, and test scores rose.

AP summary of his record · Washington Times/AP

Stable management helped the city avoid the credit troubles of New York and Philadelphia. In 2010 Daley said Chicago was in better financial shape than in 1989 and that he never 'kicks the can.'

Richard M. Daley · American Banker (1991); WBEZ

What critics say

The parking meter lease will cost the city an estimated $974M because it chased short-term revenue without public review.

Chicago Inspector General David Hoffman (2009) · WBEZ

'I would not do that deal' on the meters. He 'didn't solve the pension problem,' and Meigs should have been closed 'in the daylight.'

Bill Daley, his brother · Chicago Sun-Times

The Plan for Transformation had 'noble intentions but also unintended consequences' and in some ways reinforced historical divisions. Moving people between areas 'is not a transformation.'

Prof. Andrew Greenlee; Ald. Leslie Hairston (5th) · Chicago Sun-Times/BGA

He 'is leaving the bills behind' by drawing down privatization reserves to avoid tax hikes. Critics also cited machine-style rule, City Hall scandals and contracts for friends.

Richard Ciccarone (municipal analyst); AP summary of critics · Bond Buyer; Washington Times/AP

Sources and method

City figures: CPD annual reports and CompStat (murders), U.S. Census Bureau estimates (population), CTA ridership data on the City data portal, CPS budget appendices (enrollment), BLS via FRED (metro unemployment), City Clerk appropriation ordinances and the City data portal (Corporate Fund), and Moody’s actions reported by the Bond Buyer, the Civic Federation and the City. Murder rates are calculated from CPD counts and Census population.