Data · Segregation

Segregation in Chicago: how it compares, how it was built and what it costs

Chicago's neighborhoods are still largely divided by race. In 2020 the metro area's Black-white segregation index was 73.8, meaning about 74 percent of Black residents would have to move for Black and white residents to be evenly spread. That is down from 89.1 in 1980 but well above the national average of 55.2. The divide was built over a century by private practices and public policy, and it still shapes income, health and safety.

73.8

Black-white segregation index

Chicago metro, 2020; U.S. average 55.2

−15.3 pts

Change since 1980

Down from 89.1 in 1980

4th

Most segregated of 119 large U.S. cities

Multi-group measure, 2020 Census

$4.4B

Regional income lost each year

Compared with segregation at the median of large metros

Sources: Brown University (Logan and Stults) ↗ · Othering & Belonging Institute, UC Berkeley ↗ · Urban Institute and Metropolitan Planning Council ↗

01 · Over time

Segregation has fallen for 40 years, slowly

Chicago’s Black-white index fell from 89.1 in 1980 to 73.8 in 2020, about 15 points in 40 years. Dallas, Los Angeles and Houston fell further over the same period. The Latino-white index fell from 65.0 to 55.0.

Black and white residents, 1980 to 2020

Dissimilarity index, metro area, 0 to 100. Higher is more segregated.

3040506070809010019801990200020102020Chicago 89.1New York 74.3Chicago 73.8Philadelphia 70.2Los Angeles 59.7Houston 57.2Dallas 50.9

Latino and white residents, 1980 to 2020

Dissimilarity index, metro area, 0 to 100. Higher is more segregated.

3040506070809010019801990200020102020Chicago 65.0Los Angeles 61.0Philadelphia 60.0New York 58.8Chicago 55.0Dallas 50.0Houston 49.9

Source: Logan and Stults, Brown University Diversity and Disparities, 2021 ↗. The dissimilarity index is the share of one group that would have to move for the two groups to be evenly spread across neighborhoods. Scores above 60 are generally considered very high

02 · Compared with other metros

Among the most segregated large metros in the country

Of the largest U.S. metro areas, only New York is more segregated for Black and white residents. For Latino and white residents, Chicago ranks fourth of 10. Using a measure that covers every racial and ethnic group, Chicago is the fourth most segregated of 119 U.S. cities with more than 200,000 people.

Black and white residents, 2020

Dissimilarity index by metro area. The dashed bar is the U.S. average.

New York74.3
Chicago73.8
Philadelphia70.2
Los Angeles59.7
Atlanta58.5
Houston57.2
U.S. average55.2
Dallas50.9

Latino and white residents, 2020

Dissimilarity index by metro area.

Los Angeles61.0
Philadelphia60.0
New York58.8
Chicago55.0
Dallas50.0
Houston49.9
San Diego47.1
Phoenix46.4
Fort Worth42.1
San Antonio41.3

Source: Logan and Stults, Brown University Diversity and Disparities, 2021 ↗ · Othering & Belonging Institute, UC Berkeley ↗. Metro areas are the largest listed in the report’s tables

03 · Population

The city’s Black population peaked in 1980

Chicago’s Black population grew from about 492,000 in 1950 to nearly 1.2 million in 1980 as the Great Migration continued. It has fallen since, to about 801,000 in 2020, down 33% from the peak.

00.3M0.6M0.9M1.2M492K1950813K19601,103K19701,197K19801,088K19901,065K2000888K2010801K2020

Source: U.S. Census Bureau ↗. The definition changes in 2000: earlier counts are a single race, and 2000–2020 counts are “Black alone,” including Hispanic Black residents. Non-Hispanic Black alone was 1,053,739 in 2000, 872,286 in 2010 and 787,551 in 2020.

04 · What it costs

Segregation costs the whole region

The Cost of Segregation estimated that the region gives up billions of dollars in income every year because of segregation. Reducing it is a growth strategy as well as a question of fairness. The 2017 study modeled what would change if the Chicago region’s segregation fell to the median of large U.S. metros.

$4.4B

Added income a year for the region if segregation fell to the median of large U.S. metros

Urban Institute and Metropolitan Planning Council, The Cost of Segregation, 2017 ↗

30%

Lower homicide rate in the same scenario, 4.6 instead of 6.6 per 100,000

Urban Institute and Metropolitan Planning Council, The Cost of Segregation, 2017 ↗

83,000

More residents with bachelor's degrees in the same scenario

Urban Institute and Metropolitan Planning Council, The Cost of Segregation, 2017 ↗

$3.2–4.0B

Taken from Black families through contract selling in the 1950s and 1960s, in 2019 dollars

Samuel DuBois Cook Center, Duke University, 2019 ↗

05 · History

How Chicago's segregation was built

The divide was built over a century, by private practices and by public policy at every level of government.

  1. 1915–1970

    The Great Migration

    More than 500,000 Black Southerners moved to Chicago. Discrimination and violence confined most of them to a narrow Black Belt on the South Side.

    Chicago Collections; U.S. Census Bureau ↗

  2. 1919

    Race riot

    After Eugene Williams, a Black teenager, drowned when a white man struck him with a stone at the lakefront, five days of violence left 38 people dead and 537 injured.

    Northwestern University, Homicide in Chicago 1870–1930 ↗

  3. 1927–1948

    Restrictive covenants

    The Chicago Real Estate Board promoted deed clauses barring Black buyers. By the 1940s they covered 38 of the 85 square miles of residential land south of North Avenue. The Supreme Court made them unenforceable in 1948.

    Encyclopedia of Chicago ↗

  4. 1935–1940s

    Federal lending rules

    Federal maps graded Black neighborhoods as the riskiest, and the FHA's 1938 underwriting manual warned against “incompatible racial and social groups.” Historians still debate how much the maps themselves drove lending; the FHA rules carried more weight.

    WBEZ; FHA Underwriting Manual (1938); Chicago Fed research (2022) ↗

  5. 1950s–1960s

    Contract selling and blockbusting

    Shut out of mortgages, an estimated 75 to 95 percent of Black homebuyers bought on contract, with no equity until the last payment. Blockbusting occurred in 144 of the 805 census tracts that were not majority Black in 1950.

    Samuel DuBois Cook Center, Duke University (2019); Chicago Fed Letter No. 468 ↗

  6. 1950s–1969

    Public housing and highways

    The City Council rejected public housing sites in white areas, so CHA built in Black neighborhoods. A federal judge ruled this discriminatory in the 1969 Gautreaux case. The Dan Ryan Expressway, opened in the early 1960s, ran along the line between white Bridgeport and the Black Belt.

    Gautreaux v. CHA case record; WBEZ Curious City ↗

  7. 1966

    Chicago Freedom Movement

    Martin Luther King Jr. moved to the West Side to campaign for open housing and was struck by a rock in Marquette Park. The resulting agreement with City Hall was weakly enforced.

    NHPR, 2016 ↗

  8. 2000

    Plan for Transformation

    CHA began demolishing high-rise public housing, about 18,000 units, and promised 25,000 new or rehabbed homes. Critics say it displaced families and reinforced old divisions.

    Chicago Sun-Times and BGA, 2016 ↗

  9. 2020

    Still near the top

    The metro's Black-white index fell to 73.8, the lowest on record but still among the highest of any large metro area.

    Logan and Stults, Brown University Diversity and Disparities, 2021 ↗

06 · Policy

Proposals on the table

These are the main approaches being debated in Chicago. What to watch: Affordable Requirements Ordinance results, CHA mobility funding, Connected Communities projects, and the 2030 Census.

Require affordable units in more developments

Strengthen the Affordable Requirements Ordinance, which since 2021 requires 20 percent affordable units in some areas, including higher-income neighborhoods.

Allow more homes near transit and in every neighborhood

Expand the Connected Communities rules: fewer parking mandates, more density near trains, and less aldermanic power to block affordable housing.

Help families move to opportunity areas

Fund CHA's mobility counseling and higher voucher values so families can move to lower-poverty neighborhoods.