← All four mayors compared

Mayor of Chicago, 2011–2019

Rahm Emanuel

8

years in office
May 16, 2011 – May 20, 2019

How they took office

Elected in 2011 without a runoff; re-elected in a 2015 runoff

How it ended

Did not seek a third term

Before City Hall

White House chief of staff to President Obama, previously a three-term U.S. Representative from Chicago's North Side and a top aide to Bill Clinton

Report card

What changed on Emanuel’s watch

Twenty-two measures across ten major issues: four for the budget and two for each of the others. Each row compares the last full year before Emanuel took office with the last full year in office (or the latest data). Green means the measure moved in the better direction, yellow means little change (less than 3%, less than 1 point for rates, or less than 2 points for national test scores, which come from samples), and red means it moved the wrong way. Higher local taxes per resident count as worse. Dollar figures per resident are adjusted for inflation. Mayors share credit and blame with national trends, the state, the weather and the economy, so read this as a record of what happened, not a grade. Where a comparison exists, a line under the numbers shows the U.S. and the other nine of the 10 largest cities or metro areas over the same years.

10Improved1Little change8Worsened3No data for this term
IssueMeasureStart · 2010End · 2018Result
Budget

Credit rating

Moody’s rating on city bonds

At start

Aa3

At end

Ba1

Worsened

Down 7 notches

Local taxes per resident

city tax revenue per resident, 2025 dollars

$1,727

$2,400

Worsened

+39%

2010–2018

Budget deficit per resident

projected Corporate Fund gap per resident, 2025 dollars

2012 budget

$328

2019 budget

$46

The gap projected before each budget. Every budget passed closed it.

Improved

−86%

2012–2019

Pension funded ratio

% of promised benefits set aside, four city plans

46.6%

24.9%

Worsened

−21.7 points

2010–2018
Housing

New homes permitted

building permits for new homes per year

747

1,808

Improved

+142%

2010–2018

Renters paying 30%+ of income

% of renter households

54.9%

48.6%

Improved

−6.3 points

2010–2018
Public safety

Murder rate

per 100,000 residents

16.2

21.3

U.S. 4.8 → 5.1 (+6%) · other 9 largest cities, median 8.0 → 7.0 (−13%) · Chicago ranked 9th → 9th of 10 (1st = lowest)

Worsened

+31%

Violent crimes

incidents per year

30,307

25,327

Improved

−16%

2010–2018
Education

Graduation rate

CPS five-year cohort rate

55.8%

78.2%

Improved

+22.4 points

8th-grade math

% proficient, national test (NAEP)

2011

20.0%

2017

26.5%

U.S. public schools 33.5% → 33.4% · large-city average 26.0% → 26.8%

Improved

+6.5 points

Economy

Unemployment

metro area, annual average

10.5%

4.1%

U.S. 9.6% → 3.9% (−5.7 points) · other 9 largest metros, median 9.1% → 4.0% · Chicago ranked 8th → 6th of 10 (1st = lowest)

Improved

−6.4 points

2010–2018

Jobs in the city

jobs located in the city

1.01M

1.20M

U.S. payroll jobs over the same years: +14%

Improved

+18%

2010–2018
Transit

CTA rides

boardings per year

517M

468M

U.S. transit trips over the same years: −2%

Worsened

−9%

2010–2018

CTA service delivered

% of scheduled service run

—

—

No data for this term

Health

Life expectancy

years at birth

—

—

No data for this term

Overdose deaths

deaths per year

2015

411

814

Earliest data: 2015

Worsened

+98%

2015–2018
Population

Population

city residents

2.70M

2.70M

U.S. +7% · other 9 largest cities, median +12% (same years)

Little change

0%

Net migration

people moving in minus out, per year (Cook County)

2011

−12,159

−50,943

Earliest data: 2011

Worsened

−38,784 a year

2011–2018
Climate

Days with unhealthy air

air quality index above 100 (metro)

35

26

Improved

−26%

2010–2018

Flooding reports

311 requests per year

—

—

No data for this term

Livability

Park access

% of residents within a 10-minute walk

2012

90.0%

98.0%

Earliest data: 2012

Improved

+8.0 points

2012–2018

Arts and culture venues

per 100,000 residents (metro)

2014

5.1

4.8

Earliest data: 2014

Worsened

−6%

2014–2018

Years in the column headers apply to every row unless a row shows its own year. Sparklines show every year of data between the two values; each line is scaled to its own range. Rows marked "No data for this term" have no comparable figures for those years. Where a series starts after a mayor took office, the earliest year is used and noted. Unemployment, unhealthy air days and arts venues cover the metro area; net migration covers Cook County. Sources are on each issue page and the Citations page.

Elections

Feb. 22, 2011

Won outright, avoiding a runoff: Emanuel 55%, Gery Chico 25%, Miguel del Valle 9%, Carol Moseley Braun 9% (97% of precincts reporting)

Feb. 24, 2015

First round: Emanuel 45.63%, Jesus 'Chuy' Garcia 33.55%, Willie Wilson 10.66%, Bob Fioretti 7.39%. This forced a runoff.

Apr. 7, 2015

Runoff: Emanuel 56.23%, Garcia 43.77%. Emanuel raised nearly $24M to Garcia’s $6M, per NPR.

Budget and finances

  • 2011

    Inherited a $635M deficit, which his transition report projected at $700M. bondbuyer.com

  • 2012 budget

    $6.3B ($8.2B all funds), passed 50-0. bondbuyer.com

  • 2015

    Moody's downgraded the city to Ba1 (junk). The rating covered $8.1B in GO debt. news.wttw.com

  • 2016 budget

    $7.8B. It included a record property tax increase for pensions. wbez.org

  • 2019 budget

    $10.7B, passed 48-1, with no new taxes ahead of the election. chicago.suntimes.com

  • 2018

    The four pension funds were about 26% funded, with $28B unfunded. City contributions were scheduled to rise from $1.31B (2019) to $2.1B (2023). Ratings: S&P BBB+, Fitch BBB-, Kroll A, Moody's Ba1. The deficit had fallen to $98M from $635M in 2011. bondbuyer.com

  • 2019

    A large step-up in pension payments was deferred until after he left office. chicago.suntimes.com

Timeline

Decisions the mayor made or backed Events during the term

  1. 2011 Action

    His first budget, $6.3B for 2012, closed a $635M gap. It cut 550 positions, closed several police district stations and raised fees and fines without raising property or sales taxes. The council passed it 50-0. Bond Buyer

  2. 2011-2019 Action

    Tax and fee increases over his tenure totaled more than $2B, including $1.1B in property tax increases. Chicago Sun-Times

  3. 2011-2019 Action

    Aldermen credited his administration with a minimum wage increase and paid sick leave ordinances, a Neighborhood Opportunity Fund, an Immigrant Legal Defense Fund and municipal ID, and all-day kindergarten. WBEZ (Becky Vevea, May 15, 2019)

  4. 2011-2019 Action

    Other changes cited: full-day pre-K, revamped community colleges, the Riverwalk and bike lanes. NBC Chicago

  5. 2012 Action

    Longer school day: a 7-hour day for elementary schools (scaled back from a proposed 7.5 hours) and 7.5 hours for high schools. Emanuel said elementary schools had been 'stuck with 5 hours and 45 minutes.' WBEZ

  6. 2012 Event

    Chicago Teachers Union strike, the first in a generation. It followed Emanuel's cancellation of a negotiated 4% raise. Teachers voted 90% to strike and stayed out seven days. Chicago Sun-Times

  7. 2013 Action

    On May 22, 2013 the mayor-appointed Board of Education voted to close 50 schools (49 unanimously, plus Von Humboldt on a 4-2 vote). CPS cited underutilization and efficiency. WBEZ

  8. 2014-2015 Event

    Laquan McDonald, 17, was shot 16 times by a Chicago police officer in October 2014. A judge ordered the dashcam video released in November 2015, about seven months after Emanuel's runoff win. The Council approved a $5M settlement, and Emanuel fired Superintendent Garry McCarthy. Chicago Sun-Times

  9. 2015 Action

    The 2016 budget ($7.8B) included a property tax increase of roughly $543M for police and fire pensions, plus $45M a year for school construction. It also added a $9.50 monthly garbage fee and new ride-share and cab fees. The council vote was 36-14. WBEZ

  10. 2015 Event

    On May 12, 2015 Moody's cut Chicago's general obligation rating from Baa2 to Ba1 (junk), citing an Illinois Supreme Court pension ruling. Emanuel called it 'irresponsible.' WTTW

  11. 2015-2017 Event

    Former CPS CEO Barbara Byrd-Bennett was sentenced to federal prison for a kickback scheme tied to $20M-plus in no-bid contracts. Chicago Sun-Times

  12. 2016 Event

    Murders reached 780, the highest since the mid-1990s. The city was on pace for about 500 in 2018. Chicago Sun-Times

  13. 2017 Event

    In January 2017 a Justice Department investigation found 'reasonable cause to believe' CPD had a pattern or practice of excessive force, citing inadequate training and accountability. A consent decree followed, from a lawsuit filed by Attorney General Lisa Madigan. NPR via KAXE; Chicago Sun-Times

  14. 2018 Action

    On March 28, 2018 the City Council approved an $8.5B O'Hare expansion, including a new global terminal replacing Terminal 2 and 22% more gates. The related $4B borrowing passed 40-1. WTTW; Chicago Sun-Times

How people judge the record

We don’t grade mayors. Here is what named supporters and critics have said, each linked to the source.

What supporters say

His tough tax decisions on property, water, garbage and phone taxes got 'Chicago's fiscal house in order' and averted possible bankruptcy.

Ald. Gilbert Villegas (36th) · WBEZ

He is leaving the city 'in better financial shape than he found it.'

Laurence Msall, Civic Federation · Chicago Sun-Times

He made hard decisions, 'some of them painful and unpopular.' Emanuel himself said he 'never once punted on a tough decision' and brought Chicago 'back from the brink.'

Ald. Edward Burke; Rahm Emanuel · Bond Buyer; Chicago Sun-Times

National research found CPS students made the fastest academic gains in the country, and the graduation rate rose to 78.2%.

Reported by Chicago Sun-Times · Chicago Sun-Times

What critics say

The McDonald video release was timed around the election. Critics also say he ignored community input on the Lincoln Yards and The 78 zoning approvals.

Ald. Scott Waguespack (32nd) · WBEZ

The 50 school closings were his biggest blunder. Mayoral control of schools was called an 'absolute failed experiment.'

Aldermen Michelle Harris (8th) and Walter Burnett Jr. (27th); CTU President Karen Lewis · WBEZ

He was 'fearless' but failed in execution and took a paternalistic approach, especially toward Black residents. Another critic said he did not recognize the value of listening.

Delmarie Cobb (political consultant); former Ald. Joe Moore · Chicago Sun-Times

'In the working class parts of this city, this is not a popular mayor.' Critics described a 'tale of two cities,' one for the wealthy and one for the poor.

Jesse Sharkey, CTU vice president · Chicago Sun-Times

Sources and method

City figures: CPD annual reports and CompStat (murders), U.S. Census Bureau estimates (population), CTA ridership data on the City data portal, CPS budget appendices (enrollment), BLS via FRED (metro unemployment), City Clerk appropriation ordinances and the City data portal (Corporate Fund), and Moody’s actions reported by the Bond Buyer, the Civic Federation and the City. Murder rates are calculated from CPD counts and Census population.