← All four mayors compared

Mayor of Chicago, 2023–present

Brandon Johnson

3.5

years in office
May 15, 2023 – present

How they took office

Elected in a 2023 runoff

How it ended

In office; running in the Feb. 23, 2027 election

Before City Hall

Cook County commissioner, Chicago Teachers Union organizer and former CPS middle and high school teacher.

Report card

What changed on Johnson’s watch

Twenty-two measures across ten major issues: four for the budget and two for each of the others. Each row compares the last full year before Johnson took office with the last full year in office (or the latest data). Green means the measure moved in the better direction, yellow means little change (less than 3%, less than 1 point for rates, or less than 2 points for national test scores, which come from samples), and red means it moved the wrong way. Higher local taxes per resident count as worse. Dollar figures per resident are adjusted for inflation. Mayors share credit and blame with national trends, the state, the weather and the economy, so read this as a record of what happened, not a grade. Where a comparison exists, a line under the numbers shows the U.S. and the other nine of the 10 largest cities or metro areas over the same years.

11Improved6Little change5Worsened0No data for this term
IssueMeasureStart · 2022Latest · 2025Result
Budget

Credit rating

Moody’s rating on city bonds

At start

Baa3

Latest

Baa3

Little change

No change

Local taxes per resident

city tax revenue per resident, 2025 dollars

$2,510

2024

$2,656

Worsened

+6%

2022–2024

Budget deficit per resident

projected Corporate Fund gap per resident, 2025 dollars

2024 budget

$203

2026 budget

$421

The gap projected before each budget. Every budget passed closed it.

Worsened

+108%

2024–2026

Pension funded ratio

% of promised benefits set aside, four city plans

24.2%

2024

26.2%

Improved

+2.0 points

2022–2024
Housing

New homes permitted

building permits for new homes per year

1,591

1,460

Worsened

−8%

2022–2025

Renters paying 30%+ of income

% of renter households

51.5%

2024

49.2%

Improved

−2.3 points

2022–2024
Public safety

Murder rate

per 100,000 residents

26.8

15.2

Murders also fell sharply in most large U.S. cities over these years: the Council on Criminal Justice found homicides in its sample of big cities down 51% from the 2022 peak by mid-2026.

U.S. 6.6 → 4.1 (−38%) · other 9 largest cities, median 13.2 → 7.5 (−43%) · Chicago ranked 9th → 10th of 10 (1st = lowest)

Improved

−43%

Violent crimes

incidents per year

26,116

21,921

Improved

−16%

2022–2025
Education

Graduation rate

CPS five-year cohort rate

84.0%

86.9%

CPS changed its method in 2025, adding students who enrolled after 9th grade.

Improved

+2.9 points

8th-grade math

% proficient, national test (NAEP)

15.8%

2024

20.6%

U.S. public schools 25.5% → 26.9% · large-city average 20.5% → 22.7%

Improved

+4.8 points

Economy

Unemployment

metro area, annual average

4.6%

4.7%

U.S. 3.7% → 4.3% (+0.6 points) · other 9 largest metros, median 3.6% → 3.9% · Chicago ranked 9th → 8th of 10 (1st = lowest)

Little change

+0.1 points

2022–2025

Jobs in the city

jobs located in the city

1.19M

1.23M

U.S. payroll jobs over the same years: +4%

Little change

+3%

2022–2025
Transit

CTA rides

boardings per year

244M

319M

Uses CTA’s old counting method for 2025 (319M) so it matches 2022. Under the new method adopted in March 2026, 2025 was 338M.

U.S. transit trips over the same years: +30%

Improved

+31%

2022–2025

CTA service delivered

% of scheduled service run

80.4%

2024

98.1%

Monthly snapshots, not annual averages: 2022 is the CTA’s low point that year and 2024 is August.

Improved

+17.7 points

2022–2024
Health

Life expectancy

years at birth

77.2

2024

79.5

Life expectancy also recovered nationally after the pandemic.

Improved

+2.3 years

Overdose deaths

deaths per year

1,408

577

Overdose deaths also fell steeply across the U.S. in 2024 and 2025.

Improved

−59%

2022–2025
Population

Population

city residents

2.68M

2.73M

U.S. +3% · other 9 largest cities, median +3% (same years)

Little change

+2%

Net migration

people moving in minus out, per year (Cook County)

−66,243

−3,554

Census estimates. Most of the change came from higher international migration, which rose nationally too.

Improved

+62,689 a year

2022–2025
Climate

Days with unhealthy air

air quality index above 100 (metro)

15

32

Worsened

+113%

2022–2025

Flooding reports

311 requests per year

7,404

19,279

Worsened

+160%

2022–2025
Livability

Park access

% of residents within a 10-minute walk

98.0%

2026

98.0%

Little change

0.0 points

2022–2026

Arts and culture venues

per 100,000 residents (metro)

5.3

2024

5.4

Little change

+1%

2022–2024

Years in the column headers apply to every row unless a row shows its own year. Sparklines show every year of data between the two values; each line is scaled to its own range. Rows marked "No data for this term" have no comparable figures for those years. Where a series starts after a mayor took office, the earliest year is used and noted. Unemployment, unhealthy air days and arts venues cover the metro area; net migration covers Cook County. Sources are on each issue page and the Citations page.

Elections

First round, Feb. 28, 2023

Paul Vallas 32.90% (185,743), Johnson 21.63% (122,093), incumbent Lori Lightfoot 16.81% (94,890, third).

Runoff, Apr. 4, 2023

Johnson 52.16% (319,481) def. Paul Vallas 47.84% (293,033).

Budget and finances

  • 2024 budget (passed Nov 15, 2023)

    $16.6B budget passed 41-8, with no property tax increase. It used about $400M in TIF surplus and set aside $150M for migrants. cbsnews.com

  • 2025 budget (passed Dec 16, 2024)

    Council rejected Johnson's proposed $300M property tax increase and a later $68.5M version. It passed 27-23 with about $165.5M in other taxes and fees (lease tax 9% to 11%, amusement tax extended to streaming, parking and bag taxes) and kept a $270M advance pension payment. Sources conflict on size: Sun-Times says $17.3B, WTTW says $17.1B. chicago.suntimes.com

  • 2025 (Jan)

    S&P lowered Chicago's GO rating one notch to BBB, citing 'a sizable structural budgetary imbalance.' news.wttw.com

  • 2025

    Ratings as of Dec 2025, per Bond Buyer: S&P BBB with a negative outlook (revised in November); Fitch A- negative (lowered in May); Moody's Baa3 stable (lowered from positive in August); KBRA A- negative (after a January downgrade). bondbuyer.com

  • 2026 budget (Dec 2025)

    Council version replaced Johnson's proposed $16.6B plan (Crain's); the adopted budget was also about $16.6B. BGA says the council added about $317.8M in appropriations to the mayor's figure. It dropped the $100M head tax, relied on an $89.6M sale of uncollected debt that the budget office called unprecedented, and reversed Johnson's cut to advance pension payments at a net cost of $278.9M. Sources measure size differently. bettergov.org

  • 2026 (Feb 25)

    Fitch and KBRA each downgraded Chicago's GO rating from A- to BBB+ with negative outlooks. Fitch also cut the senior-lien Sales Tax Securitization Corporation bonds from AAA to AA+. bondbuyer.com

  • 2027 proposal (Oct 2026)

    Proposed $17.6B budget to close an $882M gap, including a revived head tax and a higher personal property lease tax. Pending before City Council. fox32chicago.com

Timeline

Decisions the mayor made or backed Events during the term

  1. 2023 Action

    Nominated Larry Snelling as police superintendent; the City Council confirmed him 48-0. WTTW

  2. 2023 Action

    City Council passed 36-12 an ordinance Johnson championed that requires employers to give at least 10 paid days off a year (5 sick days and 5 days for any reason). It took effect July 1, 2024, after the council delayed the original Dec. 31, 2023 start. WTTW

  3. 2023-2026 Action

    Johnson's campaign lists these accomplishments: reinstating the Department of Environment, groundwork to reopen closed mental health clinics, renter protections, and youth jobs and violence prevention spending. Chicago Sun-Times

  4. 2023-2024 Event

    Migrant arrivals: the city sheltered 46,282 people, mostly Venezuelan, starting with overflow in police stations and airports in April 2023. Inspector General David Glockner's July 2026 report put the total cost at $639.6 million and found the city 'accurately reported this spending and followed established procurement processes.' Chicago Sun-Times

  5. 2024 Action

    Announced the city would not renew the ShotSpotter gunshot-detection contract, which had cost $49 million; the city was to stop using it by Sept 22, 2024. WTTW

  6. 2024 Action

    Backed the Bring Chicago Home referendum, which would have raised the real estate transfer tax on sales over $1 million to fund homelessness programs. Voters rejected it about 53% to 47%. WBEZ

  7. 2024 Action

    City Council approved 32-17 his plan to borrow up to $1.25 billion over five years (capped at $250 million a year) for affordable housing and economic development, partly to reduce reliance on TIF districts. WTTW

  8. 2024 Event

    The entire seven-member Board of Education that Johnson appointed announced its resignation Oct 4, 2024. It came after the board refused his July directive to take a high-interest loan for pension and CTU contract costs, and amid a dispute over CEO Pedro Martinez. Axios Chicago

  9. 2024 Event

    The interim board appointed by Johnson voted unanimously in December 2024 to fire CPS CEO Pedro Martinez before the new 21-member hybrid board (10 elected, 11 appointed) took office Jan 15, 2025. Martinez sought an injunction. Axios Chicago

  10. 2025 Action

    A four-year CTU contract was ratified and approved by the Board of Education. It is estimated to cost about $1.5 billion over its life and was the first deal in 15 years reached without a strike vote. WTTW

  11. 2025 Action

    Signed an executive order on Oct 6, 2025 creating 'ICE-free zones' that bar federal immigration agents from using city property as staging areas, during DHS's 'Operation Midway Blitz' (launched Sept 8, 2025). Fox 32

  12. 2025 Action

    Applied the amusement tax to social media companies, with revenue going to a new 'Protecting CARE Fund' for mental and behavioral health. The 2026 budget anticipates $31 million; Johnson's campaign later cited $49.2 million expected this year. BGA Policy; Sun-Times

  13. 2025 Event

    City Council passed a 2026 budget without Johnson's support, rejecting his corporate head tax (30-18 on the final piece). Johnson neither signed nor vetoed it. BGA called it the first time in modern history the council passed a budget without the sitting mayor's support. CBS Chicago; BGA Policy

  14. 2025 Event

    Federal immigration enforcement surge 'Operation Midway Blitz' began Sept 8, 2025, with more than 900 arrests by early October per DHS. Ald. Jessie Fuentes was handcuffed while questioning agents. Fox 32

  15. 2025 Event

    Chicago recorded 416 homicides in 2025, down 29% from 587 in 2024 and the lowest in six decades according to CPD. Fox 32 notes violent crime also fell in many other U.S. cities in 2025. Fox 32

  16. 2026 Action

    Proposed a $17.6 billion 2027 'Fair Share' budget to close an $882 million gap. It revives a head tax ($25 per employee per month on companies with more than 125 workers, outside socio-economically disadvantaged areas) and raises the personal property lease tax (about $234 million). Fox 32; WTTW headline

How people judge the record

We don’t grade mayors. Here is what named supporters and critics have said, each linked to the source.

What supporters say

Johnson's campaign message is 'Cranes are up and crime is down.' It cites 122 murders in June-August 2026, the lowest summer total since 1965 per city and police data.

Johnson campaign · Fox 32; Chicago Sun-Times

Supporters said the paid leave ordinance helps the lowest-paid workers, who are mostly Black and Latino, care for their families. Johnson argued productivity 'actually goes up' with a protected workforce.

Johnson; ordinance sponsors including Ald. Mike Rodriguez · WTTW

Ending ShotSpotter was called a 'responsible' phase-out that shifts money to prevention. Supporters cited an Inspector General audit finding fewer than 1 in 10 alerts led to evidence of a gun-related offense.

Kennedy Bartley, United Working Families; Johnson's office · WTTW

The 2025 CTU contract was reached without a strike vote and adds enforceable class-size limits and more services for special education, bilingual and unhoused students.

CTU President Stacy Davis Gates; CPS CEO Pedro Martinez · WTTW

What critics say

Voters don't believe Johnson has been 'very successful' at his stated goals. Ald. Marty Quinn said voters see him as a 'nice guy that isn't up to running the city.'

Eric Adelstein (Giannoulias strategist); Ald. Marty Quinn · Chicago Sun-Times

Fitch cited consecutive operating deficits since 2023, heavy reliance on non-structural solutions and 'ongoing disagreements between the administration and the city council' when it downgraded the city.

Fitch Ratings · Bond Buyer

The revived head tax is a 'tax on jobs' that could push businesses to the suburbs. A group of 29 alders wants government efficiencies before any head tax or property tax increase.

Ald. Matt O'Shea (19th) and 29 alders · Fox 32

The CPS CEO firing was rushed and political. Alders and newly elected board members asked the board to wait for the new members and accused it of acting to appease Johnson and the CTU.

Alders and newly elected school board members · Axios Chicago

The paid leave ordinance was called 'poorly drafted' and said to 'devastate Chicago businesses, especially small businesses.'

Chicagoland Chamber of Commerce and business coalition · WTTW

Public opinion polls

Independent and media polls only; polls paid for by advocacy groups or campaigns are left out.

Apr 11-15, 2026Suffolk University/Chicago Tribune (500 adults, ±4.4)34% favorable, 44% unfavorable Chicago Tribune, via KDH News ↗
Published July 15, 2026 (field dates not given)UChicago Mansueto Institute for Urban Innovation23% job approval, down from 25% in December CBS News Chicago ↗
Reported Oct 2026 (field dates not given)NORC (as reported by Fox 32)22% approve, 53% disapprove, 25% undecided or no opinion FOX 32 Chicago ↗
Sources and method

City figures: CPD annual reports and CompStat (murders), U.S. Census Bureau estimates (population), CTA ridership data on the City data portal, CPS budget appendices (enrollment), BLS via FRED (metro unemployment), City Clerk appropriation ordinances and the City data portal (Corporate Fund), and Moody’s actions reported by the Bond Buyer, the Civic Federation and the City. Murder rates are calculated from CPD counts and Census population.