Issues / 05 Immigration

How should Chicago welcome newcomers and handle federal enforcement?

About 21% of Chicagoans were born abroad. The city sheltered more than 46,000 asylum seekers from 2022 to 2024, and a 2025 federal enforcement surge brought arrests and lawsuits.

CommentsUpdated Nov 19, 2026

Updated Nov 19, 2026

Comment

The trend

Share of residents born outside the U.S., 2006 to 2024

5 measures for this issue · pick one

Lines show United States, New York, Los Angeles.

% of residents born outside the U.S.Hover over or tap the chart to see each year’s value.
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey ↗. Share of city residents born outside the U.S. No standard 2020 estimates were released. The U.S. line is the national share (ACS).

In this chart · Chicago

Share of residents born outside the U.S.

% of residents born outside the U.S.

Latest (2024)Latest, 2024

22.0%

Change since 20231 year

+1.0 pts

since 2023

Change sinceChange since

2019

+1.7 pts

2014

+1.5 pts

U.S. rank (2024)U.S. rank, 2024

6th highest of 10

1st = highestAmong the 10 largest U.S. cities. 1st = highest

Back to chart ↑

Three things to know

  1. One in five Chicagoans was born abroadIn 2025, 21% of Chicago residents were born outside the U.S., about 577,000 people. That share has stayed between 20% and 22% since 2006.
  2. The 2022-24 arrivalsStarting in August 2022, Texas sent buses of asylum seekers to Chicago, and at least 46,282 arrived through 2024. The response cost $639.7 million before the separate shelters merged into the homeless system at the end of 2024.
  3. Sanctuary law and federal enforcementChicago has limited its cooperation with federal immigration agents since 1985, and a 2006 ordinance made that law. A federal operation that began in September 2025 made more than 3,600 arrests in Illinois, and the state and city are suing over it.

In numbers

Immigration in numbers

21%

Of Chicago residents born outside the U.S., 2025 (577,431 people)

U.S. Census Bureau, ACS 1-year, table B05002 ↗

46,282

Asylum seekers the city's records confirm arrived Aug. 2022-Dec. 2024 (the public dashboard reported 51,648)

City of Chicago Office of Inspector General ↗

15,000+

People in city shelters and staging areas at the peak, January 2024

City of Chicago Office of Inspector General ↗

$640M

City and grant spending on the new arrivals mission, Aug. 2022-Dec. 2024 (42% from the city's main fund)

City of Chicago Office of Inspector General ↗

26%

Of CPS students who are English learners, fall 2026 (79,878 students)

Chicago Public Schools ↗

3,600+

People arrested by immigration agents in Illinois, Sept.-Nov. 2025; more than 2,400 have been deported

ABC7 Chicago, from ICE data released to the Deportation Data Project ↗

The goal

A growing city where newcomers and long-time residents can build lives.

All goals →

Population

2,731,5852025 estimate

2031 goal: 2.75M residents · Back above the April 2020 Census base by 2029

▲ Moving the right way Compared with 2024

2,731,585

2025 estimate

2.75M residents

2031 goal

Back above the April 2020 Census base by 2029

▲ Moving the right wayCompared with 2024

Ideas on immigration

Three ideas, and the case for and against each

Each idea is designed to address the challenges and opportunities Chicago faces on immigration. For each one, you’ll find the strongest arguments for and against it, plus the tradeoff: what you gain, what you give up and who pays. Read both sides, then tell us where you land.

Idea 1 of 3

1Keep and expand Welcoming City protections

Keep the ban on city police helping federal civil immigration enforcement, and fund legal aid, English classes and other services for newcomers.

Needs a yes fromThe mayor and City Council, which wrote the Welcoming City Ordinance and fund services.

What could hold it upFederal lawsuits against sanctuary laws, and the cost of services. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Immigrants may be more willing to report crimes and testify
  2. Keeps police time focused on local crime
  3. Legal help gives people a fair hearing in immigration court

Against

  1. Federal officials say it lets people with criminal records go free instead of to ICE
  2. Keeps the city in open conflict with the federal government
  3. Risks some federal grants and more aggressive federal operations

The tradeoff

You gain

Trust between immigrant residents and police; legal help and services for newcomers

You give up

Continued conflict with the federal government and possible loss of some federal funds

Who pays

City taxpayers for services and legal aid; the city if federal grants are cut

If nothing changes

The protections stay in law, but services for newcomers depend on each year’s budget and federal grants.

What the evidence says · 2 studies

Study quality: High Largest scale tested: Program to Many cities

Idea 2 of 3

2Allow cooperation in serious-crime cases

Restore exceptions, like those in place before 2021, that let police work with federal immigration agents when someone is charged with or convicted of serious crimes.

Needs a yes fromThe City Council, which would have to amend the Welcoming City Ordinance.

What could hold it upA large Council majority that voted in 2025 not to consider it, and the state TRUST Act. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Focuses removals on people accused or convicted of serious crimes
  2. Could reduce the need for large street sweeps by federal agents
  3. Lowers conflict with Washington and risk to federal funds

Against

  1. City Council rejected it 39-11 in January 2025
  2. State law limits local help with immigration holds regardless
  3. A charge is not a conviction; people could be deported before trial

The tradeoff

You gain

More removals of people accused or convicted of serious crimes, and less friction with Washington

You give up

Some immigrant residents may avoid police; risk of deporting people before trial

Who pays

Immigrant residents and their families; police time

If nothing changes

Police keep declining federal civil immigration requests, including for people charged with serious crimes, and act only on criminal warrants.

What the evidence says · 2 studies

Study quality: High Largest scale tested: Many cities

Idea 3 of 3

3Focus on work permits and job placement

Work with the state and federal government to speed work permits, job training and English classes so newcomers can support themselves.

Needs a yes fromThe federal government for work permits, with the state and city for training and placement.

What could hold it upFederal processing times and limited funding for classes. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

No group in the table below opposes it outright on the public record; see where each one stands. Who cares and why ↓

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Newcomers who work need less shelter and public aid
  2. Fills jobs in health care, construction, food and hospitality
  3. Adds tax revenue

Against

  1. Work permits are set by federal law, outside city control
  2. Federal rules can change quickly, as they did in 2025
  3. Training and classes cost money

The tradeoff

You gain

Newcomers who support themselves and fill open jobs

You give up

Depends on federal rules the city cannot control; program costs

Who pays

City, state and federal training budgets; employers who sponsor training

If nothing changes

Newcomers keep waiting on slow federal processing, and some depend longer on shelters and aid.

What the evidence says · 1 study

Study quality: High Largest scale tested: Many cities

Your turn · Reader ideas

What would you do about immigration?

Post your idea in a sentence or two. Readers vote, and each month we review the top ideas and consider them for this page, with the case for and against.

  1. 1 Submit an idea
  2. 2 Vote for the ones you think would work
  3. 3 Each month we review the top ideas
  4. 4 The best are considered for this page
See reader ideas on every issue →

Who decides

Washington runs enforcement; the state and city decide whether local police help

WashingtonDecides

Immigration law, ICE, Border Patrol and work permits.

SpringfieldLimits local help

The TRUST Act bars help with civil enforcement.

City HallLimits help, funds services

The Welcoming City Ordinance and services for newcomers.

Cook CountyHas its own limits

Rules for the county jail, and health care for all.

Who to ask today

Brandon JohnsonMayor · elected
Kwame RaoulIllinois Attorney General · elected
LaKenya WhiteCOPA chief
Gov. JB PritzkerGovernor · elected

Biggest risk nowA federal judge was expected to rule in mid-November on whether Illinois and Chicago’s lawsuit over federal enforcement tactics can go forward.

See who’s accountable for immigration →

What to watch

Judge Sara Ellis's ruling, due Nov. 17, 2026, in Illinois and Chicago's lawsuit over federal enforcement; the pace of federal arrests in the area; the next Census estimates of international migration; and CPS English-learner enrollment.

Go deeper

The best pieces on immigration, from different points of view

Who cares and why

The people with a stake, and their point of view

Where each group stands on the ideas above, and the lens it mostly argues from. Every stance links to a public statement, vote or report; a dash means we found no public position.

Lenses GrowthEquityNeighborhoodSafety Stances ● Supports◐ Mixed○ Opposes
WhoTheir point of viewWhat they wantLens Idea 1Keep and expand Welcoming City protectionsIdea 2Allow cooperation in serious-crime casesIdea 3Focus on work permits and job placement
Immigrant residents and their families (ICIRR, National Immigrant Justice Center) Immigrants need to feel safe calling police and going to school without fear of deportation. Safety from deportation, legal status and the right to work. Equity SupportsICIRR urged council to uphold and defend the ordinanceBorderless Magazine, Jan. 16, 2025 OpposesImmigrant groups warned crime carve-out would have devastating impactBorderless Magazine, Jan. 16, 2025 SupportsNIJC urged fast work permits, called TPS a half measureBlock Club Chicago, Sept. 22, 2023
Neighborhoods that hosted shelters Residents felt left out of shelter decisions and want fairness to long-time residents in city spending. A say in siting and fair use of city money. Neighborhood — — —
Federal government (Department of Justice, Department of Homeland Security) Federal officials say local limits on cooperation obstruct immigration enforcement. Local cooperation with federal immigration enforcement. Safety OpposesDOJ sued Chicago to block Welcoming City ordinanceABC7 Chicago, 2025 SupportsDOJ said criminals were released instead of held for removalABC7 Chicago, 2025 —
Police and city officials (Mayor's Office, Chicago Police Department) City leaders say trust between immigrants and police improves safety, within limits set by state law. Community trust and compliance with state and city law. Safety SupportsMayor Johnson said Chicago will remain a welcoming cityABC7 Chicago, 2025 OpposesSupt. Snelling opposed crime carve-out, citing state law and unclear languageBorderless Magazine, Jan. 16, 2025 SupportsMayor Johnson asked DHS for streamlined work authorizationABC7 Chicago, 2023
City Council Most aldermen back the Welcoming City ordinance, while a minority want exceptions for serious crimes. Varies: keep protections, or add serious-crime exceptions. Safety SupportsCouncil voted 39-11 to table rollback of protectionsFOX 32 Chicago, 2025 MixedAlds. Lopez, Tabares proposed carve-out; majority tabled itFOX 32 Chicago, 2025 —
Employers and schools (Illinois Manufacturers' Association, Chicago Board of Education) Employers need workers for hard-to-fill jobs, and schools want students to attend without fear. Work permits for newcomers and safe schools for all students. Growth SupportsSchool board unanimously reaffirmed limits on ICE access to schoolsChalkbeat Chicago, Nov. 15, 2024 — SupportsIllinois Manufacturers' Association said employers struggle to hire, backed permitsABC7 Chicago, 2023

The ideas

1 Keep and expand Welcoming City protections

2 Allow cooperation in serious-crime cases

3 Focus on work permits and job placement

– means no public position found. Tap a group for details and sources.

Point of view. Immigrants need to feel safe calling police and going to school without fear of deportation.

What they want. Safety from deportation, legal status and the right to work.

Idea 1: Supports. ICIRR urged council to uphold and defend the ordinance
Borderless Magazine, Jan. 16, 2025 ↗

Idea 2: Opposes. Immigrant groups warned crime carve-out would have devastating impact
Borderless Magazine, Jan. 16, 2025 ↗

Idea 3: Supports. NIJC urged fast work permits, called TPS a half measure
Block Club Chicago, Sept. 22, 2023 ↗

Common ground

Most groups agree newcomers should be able to work legally; they split sharply over whether local police should cooperate with federal immigration agents, including in serious-crime cases.

Help improve this page

This is the initial version. It gets better with your expertise, ideas and experience.

Review this issue

For academics, policy professionals and practitioners. Tell us what is wrong, misleading or missing, and get credited for your review.

Volunteer to review

Share an idea

For anyone with a good idea or lived experience of this issue. Readers vote, and the top ideas are considered for this page each month.

Share an idea

Report an error

Spot a figure that looks wrong? Tell us, with a source if you can. Corrections are dated and explained at the bottom of the page.

Report an error

No comments yet. Be the first to share evidence, experience or a counterpoint.