Issues / 06 Economic growth and jobs

How can Chicago grow businesses and jobs in every neighborhood?

Chicago has a diverse economy, but job growth has trailed peer cities and downtown office vacancy remains high. Growth funds services and creates opportunity.

CommentsUpdated Nov 19, 2026

Updated Nov 19, 2026

Comment

The trend

Unemployment rate, 2005 to 2025

8 measures for this issue · pick one

Lines show United States, New York, Los Angeles.

Percent of labor forceHover over or tap the chart to see each year’s value.
Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics ↗. Annual averages for each metro area; the extra line is the City of Chicago. Dallas and Fort Worth use their own metro divisions. The U.S. line is the national unemployment rate (BLS).

See how this differs across Chicago →

In this chart · Chicago

Unemployment rate

Percent of labor force

Latest (2025)Latest, 2025

4.7%

Change since 20241 year

−0.4 pts

since 2024

Change sinceChange since

2020

−5.1 pts

2015

−1.3 pts

2005

−1.3 pts

U.S. rank (2025)U.S. rank, 2025

8th of 10

1st = lowestAmong the 10 largest U.S. cities. 1st = lowest

Global rankGlobal rank

3rd of 10

Unemployment rate, lower is betterUnemployment rate, lower is better

Back to chart ↑

Three things to know

  1. Unemployment is risingThe Chicago-area rate was 4.8% in September 2026 (seasonally adjusted), up from 4.4% a year earlier and above the 2025 average of 4.7%. It was 3.9% in 2019.
  2. Job growth trails peersChicago's economy is diverse, but job growth has lagged peer metros.
  3. Downtown is still recoveringOffice vacancy remains high, which is why office-to-housing conversions are on the table.

In numbers

Jobs in numbers

4.8%

Chicago-area unemployment rate, September 2026 (seasonally adjusted); 4.4% a year earlier

BLS via FRED ↗

10.5%

Annual average at the post-recession peak in 2010

BLS via FRED ↗

9.8%

Annual average in 2020, during the pandemic

BLS via FRED ↗

The goal

More jobs and businesses in every part of the city.

All goals →

Chicago-area unemployment rate

4.8%September 2026, seasonally adjusted

2031 goal: 3.9% unemployed · The 2019 annual average

▲ Moving the wrong way Compared with 2025 average

4.8%

September 2026, seasonally adjusted

3.9% unemployed

2031 goal

The 2019 annual average

▲ Moving the wrong wayCompared with 2025 average

Vs U.S. citiesBehind peers · 8th of 10

Chicago 4.7%

Worst: Los Angeles 5.3%Best: Phoenix 3.8%

Metro unemployment rate

2025 annual average · BLS Local Area Unemployment Statistics ↗ · Goals are Chicago Explainer’s own and are raised when Chicago reaches them.

Ideas for more jobs and growth

Five ideas, and the case for and against each

Each idea is designed to address the challenges and opportunities Chicago faces on jobs and the economy. For each one, you’ll find the strongest arguments for and against it, plus the tradeoff: what you gain, what you give up and who pays. Read both sides, then tell us where you land.

Idea 1 of 5

1Make it easier to start and grow a business

Faster permits and licenses, fewer fees, one-stop service.

Needs a yes fromThe mayor’s business and buildings departments, and the City Council for rule changes.

What could hold it upStaffing, old permit systems and approvals that wait on committees. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

No group in the table below opposes it outright on the public record; see where each one stands. Who cares and why ↓

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Low cost to the city
  2. Helps small and neighborhood businesses most
  3. Speeds openings and hiring

Against

  1. Requires sustained management focus
  2. Departments resist process change
  3. Benefits are slow to appear

The tradeoff

You gain

Faster openings and more jobs

You give up

Less review of some projects

Who pays

Little direct cost; some neighbors lose oversight

If nothing changes

Openings and expansions keep waiting on multi-step permits, licenses and committee approvals.

What the evidence says · 1 study

Study quality: Medium Largest scale tested: Many cities

Idea 2 of 5

2Convert offices to housing

Use incentives to turn empty offices into apartments, as on LaSalle Street.

Needs a yes fromThe planning department and the City Council, which approve TIF support for each conversion.

What could hold it upHigh building costs and questions about using TIF downtown. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

No group in the table below opposes it outright on the public record; see where each one stands. Who cares and why ↓

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Brings residents and activity downtown
  2. Reuses empty buildings
  3. Supports Loop shops and restaurants

Against

  1. Requires public subsidy
  2. Only some buildings are suitable
  3. Long timelines

The tradeoff

You gain

Fills empty downtown buildings and adds homes

You give up

Public subsidy per home; money not spent elsewhere

Who pays

Taxpayers, through subsidies or tax breaks

If nothing changes

Downtown office vacancy stays high, and falling office values shift more of the property tax bill to other owners.

What the evidence says · 2 programs

Study quality: Low Largest scale tested: Program

Idea 3 of 5

3Targeted business incentives

Tax increment financing and deals to win specific employers and projects.

Needs a yes fromThe planning department and the City Council for TIF, and the state for its own incentives.

What could hold it upA tight city budget and doubts about whether incentives pay off. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Can win large projects and headquarters
  2. Directs investment to struggling areas
  3. Leverages private capital

Against

  1. Can favor politically connected firms
  2. Diverts property tax revenue
  3. Many projects would happen anyway

The tradeoff

You gain

Can land a major employer and its jobs

You give up

Tax revenue given up; other businesses pay the full rate

Who pays

Taxpayers and competing businesses

If nothing changes

Employers that compare incentive packages across cities keep choosing places that offer more.

What the evidence says · 3 studies

Study quality: Medium to High Largest scale tested: Citywide to Many cities

Idea 4 of 5

4Steer investment to South and West Side business corridors

Use city land, grants and loans to bring stores, offices and jobs to commercial streets that lost them, as the Invest South/West program began doing in 2019.

Needs a yes fromThe Department of Planning and Development, with City Council votes on land sales and TIF.

What could hold it upDeveloper interest, gaps in lending and the city’s budget limits. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

  • Fiscal watchdogs · Has concerns. Civic Federation was encouraged by the $1.25B development bond but saw gaps in planning. Civic Federation, 2024 ↗
Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Brings jobs and services closer to residents who lack them
  2. Puts vacant land and buildings back to use
  3. Signals to private lenders that an area is worth backing

Against

  1. Results so far have been slow and uneven
  2. Public money may prop up projects that would not survive alone
  3. The city picks which neighborhoods and projects win

The tradeoff

You gain

Jobs and services in neighborhoods that lost them

You give up

Subsidies that could go elsewhere

Who pays

City taxpayers, through TIF and bond money

If nothing changes

Vacant storefronts and lots stay common on South and West Side commercial streets, where unemployment is highest.

Idea 5 of 5

5Train and hire residents of high-unemployment neighborhoods

Fund job training tied to employers, transitional jobs and local-hiring goals on city projects for residents of the neighborhoods with the most unemployment.

Needs a yes fromThe mayor and the Chicago Cook Workforce Partnership, with City Council for local-hire rules.

What could hold it upUneven program results and employer demand. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

No group in the table below opposes it outright on the public record; see where each one stands. Who cares and why ↓

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Targets areas where unemployment runs above 15%
  2. Connects training to real openings
  3. Local hiring keeps public dollars in the city

Against

  1. Training programs vary widely in results
  2. Local-hire rules can raise project costs
  3. Employers may not hire at the scale promised

The tradeoff

You gain

Jobs and income for residents with the fewest

You give up

Program costs and some higher project costs

Who pays

City, state and federal workforce funds

If nothing changes

Unemployment in mostly Black community areas stays near 16%, about three times the rate in mostly white areas.

Your turn · Reader ideas

What would you do about jobs and the economy?

Post your idea in a sentence or two. Readers vote, and each month we review the top ideas and consider them for this page, with the case for and against.

  1. 1 Submit an idea
  2. 2 Vote for the ones you think would work
  3. 3 Each month we review the top ideas
  4. 4 The best are considered for this page
See reader ideas on every issue →

Who decides

City Hall sets the rules for doing business; Springfield sets most taxes

City HallDecides

Licenses, permits, zoning and TIF deals.

SpringfieldSets taxes

State taxes and the biggest incentive deals.

Cook CountyValues property

Assessments and business tax breaks.

Your alderpersonHas a say

Zoning and city land deals in the ward.

Who to ask today

Brandon JohnsonMayor · elected
Ciere BoatrightPlanning and Development Commissioner
Ald. Gilbert VillegasZoning Committee chair
Gov. JB PritzkerGovernor · elected

Biggest risk nowNew business taxes in the mayor’s 2027 budget, including a per-employee tax on large employers, face a Council majority that opposes them.

See who’s accountable for the economy →

What to watch

Monthly jobs reports, headquarters moves, office conversions and business formation.

Go deeper

The best pieces on economic growth and jobs, from different points of view

Who cares and why

The people with a stake, and their point of view

Where each group stands on the ideas above, and the lens it mostly argues from. Every stance links to a public statement, vote or report; a dash means we found no public position.

Lenses GrowthEquityLaborNeighborhoodFiscal Stances ● Supports◐ Mixed○ Opposes
WhoTheir point of viewWhat they wantLens Idea 1Make it easier to start and grow a businessIdea 2Convert offices to housingIdea 3Targeted business incentivesIdea 4Steer investment to South and West Side business corridorsIdea 5Train and hire residents of high-unemployment neighborhoods
Small business owners (Small Business Advocacy Council) Owners say costs, slow permits and licensing, and safety make it hard to open and grow. Faster, clearer permits and licenses at lower cost Growth SupportsSBAC's Elliot Richardson wants a City Hall point person, clear denialsWashington Examiner, 2025 — — — —
Large employers (Chicagoland Chamber of Commerce, Civic Committee) Large employers focus on taxes, talent and predictable rules. Lower tax burden and predictable, efficient regulation Growth SupportsChamber sought 'clarity, efficiency' in rules; opposed head taxChicagoland Chamber of Commerce, 2026 — SupportsChamber praised state incentives for manufacturers and business recruitmentChicagoland Chamber of Commerce, 2025 — —
Workers and unions (Chicago Federation of Labor, Chicago Teachers Union) Unions focus on wages, job quality and whether public money benefits workers. Good-paying jobs and public dollars that benefit workers Labor — — — — —
Neighborhood development groups (LISC Chicago, local development corporations) These groups want investment and new businesses outside downtown. More capital and grants for South and West Side corridors Neighborhood — — — — —
City Hall (Mayor Johnson, City Council) City leaders push red-tape cuts and neighborhood grants but differ on large tax breaks. Growth in every neighborhood with fair shares for residents Equity SupportsJohnson launched Cut the Tape for Small BusinessCitizen Newspaper Group, 2025 SupportsJohnson and Loop aldermen back LaSalle conversions; Black Caucus sought minority participationChicago Sun-Times, April 14, 2025 — SupportsJohnson awarded $20 million in grants to neighborhood projects, mostly South and West SideCity of Chicago, May 2025 SupportsMayor's office runs hiring events tied to training in the most disinvested areasCity of Chicago, March 2025
Fiscal watchdogs (Civic Federation, Illinois Policy Institute, Better Government Association) Watchdogs question whether subsidies pay off and favor simpler rules for all businesses. Fewer special deals, simpler rules for everyone Fiscal SupportsIllinois Policy urged citywide licensing and permit reformIllinois Policy Institute, 2015 — OpposesIllinois Policy says TIFs raise taxes; dissolve unneeded districtsIllinois Policy Institute, 2025 MixedCivic Federation was encouraged by the $1.25B development bond but saw gaps in planningCivic Federation, 2024 —

The ideas

1 Make it easier to start and grow a business

2 Convert offices to housing

3 Targeted business incentives

4 Steer investment to South and West Side business corridors

5 Train and hire residents of high-unemployment neighborhoods

– means no public position found. Tap a group for details and sources.

Point of view. Owners say costs, slow permits and licensing, and safety make it hard to open and grow.

What they want. Faster, clearer permits and licenses at lower cost

Idea 1: Supports. SBAC's Elliot Richardson wants a City Hall point person, clear denials
Washington Examiner, 2025 ↗

Common ground

Most groups agree it should be faster and cheaper to open and run a business in Chicago; they split on whether targeted tax breaks and subsidies are worth their cost to taxpayers.

Help improve this page

This is the initial version. It gets better with your expertise, ideas and experience.

Review this issue

For academics, policy professionals and practitioners. Tell us what is wrong, misleading or missing, and get credited for your review.

Volunteer to review

Share an idea

For anyone with a good idea or lived experience of this issue. Readers vote, and the top ideas are considered for this page each month.

Share an idea

Report an error

Spot a figure that looks wrong? Tell us, with a source if you can. Corrections are dated and explained at the bottom of the page.

Report an error

No comments yet. Be the first to share evidence, experience or a counterpoint.