Issues / 08 Budget and fiscal health

How can Chicago close recurring deficits while funding the services that help the city grow?

The city faces a structural gap between what it spends and what it collects, driven largely by pension obligations and debt. In December 2025 the City Council passed a 2026 budget over the mayor’s objections, without his proposed per-employee tax on large employers. In October 2026 Mayor Johnson proposed a $17.6 billion 2027 budget that closes an $882 million gap with no property tax increase and brings back that tax at $25 per employee per month for companies with more than 125 workers.

CommentsUpdated Nov 19, 2026

Updated Nov 19, 2026

Comment

The trend

Operating budget per resident, 2005 to 2023

6 measures for this issue · pick one

Lines show New York, Los Angeles.

Local government spending per resident (city plus overlapping county, schools and districts), 2023 dollarsHover over or tap the chart to see each year’s value.
Source: Lincoln Institute of Land Policy, Fiscally Standardized Cities ↗. Spending per resident by the city plus its share of the county, school district and other local governments that serve its residents, so cities that run schools (like New York) compare fairly with those that do not (like Chicago). In 2023 dollars.

In this chart · Chicago

Operating budget per resident

Local government spending per resident (city plus overlapping county, schools and districts), 2023 dollars

Latest (2023)Latest, 2023

$10,659

Change since 20221 year

+3%

since 2022

Change sinceChange since

2018

+28%

2013

+32%

U.S. rank (2023)U.S. rank, 2023

3rd highest of 10

1st = highestAmong the 10 largest U.S. cities. 1st = highest

Back to chart ↑

Three things to know

  1. The gap keeps coming backEvery budget year since 2020 has started with a projected gap. The September 2026 forecast puts the 2027 gap at $882 million.
  2. Pensions and debt drive itThe structural gap comes mostly from pension obligations and debt, so one-time fixes close a year without closing the gap.
  3. Three paths, each with a costNew revenue, spending cuts and growing the tax base all close part of the gap. Each one shifts who pays.

In numbers

The budget in numbers

$882M

Projected gap for 2027, from the September 2026 forecast

City of Chicago 2027 Budget Forecast ↗

$1.02B

Projected gap by 2029 if nothing changes

City of Chicago 2027 Budget Forecast ↗

8 of 8

Budget years since 2020 that started with a projected gap

City budget forecasts, 2020 to 2027 ↗

Try it yourself

Balance the 2027 budget

Close the $882 million gap with new revenue, cuts, one-time fixes or investments in growth, then see the five-year outlook, who pays, the pressure on jobs and residents, and the credit rating risk.

Open the budget simulator →

The goal

Pay for the services Chicago needs with balanced budgets that do not rely on one-time fixes.

All goals →

Projected budget gap

$882M2027 forecast

2031 goal: $0 gap · A structurally balanced budget

▼ Moving the right way Compared with 2026

$882M

2027 forecast

$0 gap

2031 goal

A structurally balanced budget

▼ Moving the right wayCompared with 2026

Vs U.S. citiesBehind peers · Last of 10

Chicago BBB

Worst: Chicago BBBBest: San Antonio AAA

General obligation credit rating (S&P)

Latest as of Nov 2026 · S&P Global Ratings, via city disclosures ↗ · Goals are Chicago Explainer’s own and are raised when Chicago reaches them.

Ideas to balance the budget

Four ideas, and the case for and against each

Each idea is designed to address the challenges and opportunities Chicago faces on the budget. For each one, you’ll find the strongest arguments for and against it, plus the tradeoff: what you gain, what you give up and who pays. Read both sides, then tell us where you land.

Idea 1 of 4

1Raise new revenue

New or higher taxes and fees, such as a per-employee tax on large employers or higher service fees.

Needs a yes fromThe City Council, which must approve any new city tax; some taxes also need state permission.

What could hold it upA Council majority opposed to the employer tax, and an election in February. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Protects police, fire and other core services
  2. Avoids layoffs during a weak economy
  3. Can target larger businesses rather than homeowners

Against

  1. Raises the cost of creating jobs in Chicago
  2. Encourages employers to locate in the suburbs
  3. Does not fix the pension and debt drivers

The tradeoff

You gain

Protects services and pension payments

You give up

Higher costs for the people or businesses taxed; some may locate elsewhere

Who pays

Taxpayers and businesses targeted by the new tax

If nothing changes

The gap, $882 million for 2027, has to be closed with cuts or one-time fixes instead, and it comes back the next year.

What the evidence says · 3 studies

Study quality: Low to High Largest scale tested: Citywide to Many cities

Idea 2 of 4

2Cut and restructure spending

Efficiency reviews, consolidation of departments and attrition.

Needs a yes fromThe mayor and finance team, who propose the budget, and the City Council, which must pass it.

What could hold it upLabor contracts, pension costs set in state law, and the services residents rely on. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Addresses the recurring costs behind recurring gaps
  2. Signals discipline to bond markets
  3. Can find savings in overtime and duplication

Against

  1. Hard to cut enough without visible service cuts
  2. Labor contracts limit what can change
  3. Savings estimates are often overstated

The tradeoff

You gain

Lower recurring costs without new taxes

You give up

Fewer services or staff; possible layoffs

Who pays

Residents who rely on the services cut, and city workers

If nothing changes

Costs keep growing faster than revenue, so the gap returns each year and is filled with new taxes, borrowing or one-time money.

What the evidence says · 2 studies

Study quality: Low to Medium Largest scale tested: Citywide to Many cities

Idea 3 of 4

3Grow the tax base

Prioritize population and job growth so existing tax rates raise more.

Needs a yes fromThe City Council, through zoning and permits, plus state and county tax policy.

What could hold it upSlow approvals, high property taxes and a smaller flow of immigrants. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

No group in the table below opposes it outright on the public record; see where each one stands. Who cares and why ↓

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Raises revenue without raising rates
  2. Aligns budget health with prosperity
  3. Spreads fixed pension costs over more people

Against

  1. Takes years to show up in revenue
  2. Does not close this year’s gap
  3. Depends on factors outside city control

The tradeoff

You gain

More revenue without raising tax rates

You give up

Does not close this year’s gap; depends on other policies working

Who pays

Little direct cost; growth also brings new service costs

If nothing changes

Each budget keeps leaning on the same taxpayers to cover rising pension and service costs.

What the evidence says · 2 studies

Study quality: Low to Medium Largest scale tested: Citywide to Many cities

Idea 4 of 4

4Get a bigger share of state revenue

Press Springfield to restore the share of state income tax sent to cities, which was cut after 2011, so Chicago relies less on local taxes.

Needs a yes fromThe General Assembly and the governor, who set how state revenue is shared.

What could hold it upA state budget with its own gap, and requests from every other city. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

No group in the table below opposes it outright on the public record; see where each one stands. Who cares and why ↓

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Eases pressure on property and sales taxes
  2. A goal shared by suburbs and downstate cities
  3. Recurring money rather than one-time fixes

Against

  1. Depends on a state with its own budget gap
  2. Other cities compete for the same money
  3. Can take years of lobbying with no guarantee

The tradeoff

You gain

Recurring revenue without a new city tax

You give up

Money the state would spend on other priorities

Who pays

State taxpayers, including Chicagoans

If nothing changes

The city keeps paying rising pension costs mostly from local property, sales and fee revenue.

Your turn · Reader ideas

What would you do about the budget?

Post your idea in a sentence or two. Readers vote, and each month we review the top ideas and consider them for this page, with the case for and against.

  1. 1 Submit an idea
  2. 2 Vote for the ones you think would work
  3. 3 Each month we review the top ideas
  4. 4 The best are considered for this page
See reader ideas on every issue →

Who decides

The mayor proposes the budget; the City Council decides

City HallDecides

Mayor proposes; the Council must pass a budget by Dec. 31.

SpringfieldSets rules

State law sets pension benefits and many tax limits.

Rating agenciesSet borrowing costs

Three of four rate Chicago’s debt with negative outlooks.

Other governmentsShare the tax base

CPS, the county and parks levy the same properties.

Who to ask today

Brandon JohnsonMayor · elected
Ashlee GabryschChief Financial Officer
Ald. Jason ErvinBudget Committee chair
Ald. Pat DowellFinance Committee chair

Biggest risk nowThe mayor’s 2027 budget revives a per-employee tax on large employers that a majority of the Council opposes. The budget is due by Dec. 31.

See who’s accountable for the budget →

What to watch

The City Council vote on the 2027 budget, due by Dec. 31, including the per-employee tax on large employers; credit rating actions; pension contributions and any state pension changes.

Go deeper

The best pieces on budget and fiscal health, from different points of view

Who cares and why

The people with a stake, and their point of view

Where each group stands on the ideas above, and the lens it mostly argues from. Every stance links to a public statement, vote or report; a dash means we found no public position.

Lenses GrowthEquityLaborFiscal Stances ● Supports◐ Mixed○ Opposes
WhoTheir point of viewWhat they wantLens Idea 1Raise new revenueIdea 2Cut and restructure spendingIdea 3Grow the tax baseIdea 4Get a bigger share of state revenue
Mayor's office Says the city needs new recurring revenue from large employers to avoid service cuts and layoffs. New corporate revenue that protects programs and city jobs Equity Supports2027 plan has $664M in new taxes, including a head taxChicago Sun-Times, Oct. 26, 2026 MixedMayor's office calls cut-hunting 'loose change'; favors progressive revenueChicago Sun-Times, Sept. 24, 2026 SupportsJohnson: Cut the Tape makes it easier to start businessesCity of Chicago, May 2025 SupportsJohnson led mayors asking Springfield to raise the local income tax shareCapitol News Illinois, 2026
City Council majority Rejects the per-employee tax on large employers and wants the city to cut recurring costs before asking taxpayers for more. Lower recurring costs, no employer tax or property tax hike Fiscal MixedPassed 2026 budget with bag, ride-share, liquor taxes, no head taxABC7 Chicago, 2025 Supports29 aldermen: cut recurring costs before asking anyone to pay moreCPA Practice Advisor, Sept. 28, 2026 Supports29-alderman letter says the city should court employersCPA Practice Advisor, Sept. 28, 2026 —
Business groups (Chicagoland Chamber, Civic Committee) Oppose taxes on jobs and cloud services and say growth is the way out of deficits. No per-employee tax; smaller city payroll; policies that attract employers Growth OpposesCivic Committee, Chicagoland Chamber vow to block head and cloud taxesChicago Sun-Times, Oct. 21, 2026 SupportsCivic Committee urges buyouts and a right-sized city workforceChicago Sun-Times, Sept. 24, 2026 SupportsChicagoland Chamber: best fix for fiscal challenges is growthCapitol Fax, Oct. 16, 2025 —
Public sector unions and allies (CTU, AFSCME Council 31) Want the wealthy and large corporations taxed so jobs, wages and pensions are protected. Revenue from those most able to pay, so services, jobs and pensions are protected Labor SupportsCTU's Davis Gates: tax the wealthiest corporations and individualsCapitol Fax, Oct. 16, 2025 OpposesAFSCME Local 1215 protested cuts to library positionsSteve Morrill, 2025 — —
Bond rating agencies (S&P, Moody's, Fitch) Look for recurring fixes to the structural deficit and steady pension funding. Structural balance and full pension contributions Fiscal SupportsS&P: recurring revenue could return outlook to stableThe Bond Buyer, 2025 MixedS&P: spending cuts could help, but faulted cut to pension paymentsThe Bond Buyer, 2025 — —
Fiscal watchdogs (Civic Federation) Says recent budgets lean on new revenue and one-time money instead of structural cuts. Structural savings, shared burden, and less one-time borrowing Fiscal MixedCivic Federation: budget relies on revenue over structural cutsCivic Federation, 2025 SupportsCivic Federation urges cost cuts now and labor sharing the burdenCivic Federation, 2026 SupportsCivic Federation: adopted budget 'does little to promote economic growth,' 2026Civic Federation —

The ideas

1 Raise new revenue

2 Cut and restructure spending

3 Grow the tax base

4 Get a bigger share of state revenue

– means no public position found. Tap a group for details and sources.

Point of view. Says the city needs new recurring revenue from large employers to avoid service cuts and layoffs.

What they want. New corporate revenue that protects programs and city jobs

Idea 1: Supports. 2027 plan has $664M in new taxes, including a head tax
Chicago Sun-Times, Oct. 26, 2026 ↗

Idea 2: Mixed. Mayor's office calls cut-hunting 'loose change'; favors progressive revenue
Chicago Sun-Times, Sept. 24, 2026 ↗

Idea 3: Supports. Johnson: Cut the Tape makes it easier to start businesses
City of Chicago, May 2025 ↗

Idea 4: Supports. Johnson led mayors asking Springfield to raise the local income tax share
Capitol News Illinois, 2026 ↗

Common ground

Most groups agree the city has a recurring deficit that one-time fixes will not solve; they split on whether to close it mainly with new taxes on large employers or mainly with spending cuts and growth.

Help improve this page

This is the initial version. It gets better with your expertise, ideas and experience.

Review this issue

For academics, policy professionals and practitioners. Tell us what is wrong, misleading or missing, and get credited for your review.

Volunteer to review

Share an idea

For anyone with a good idea or lived experience of this issue. Readers vote, and the top ideas are considered for this page each month.

Share an idea

Report an error

Spot a figure that looks wrong? Tell us, with a source if you can. Corrections are dated and explained at the bottom of the page.

Report an error

No comments yet. Be the first to share evidence, experience or a counterpoint.