Explainer · Police settlements

Should Chicago borrow to pay police misconduct settlements?

Payouts for police misconduct hit a record in 2025, nearly three times what the city budgeted. The mayor wants to borrow $481 million to cover them. What drives the cost, what borrowing adds and what other cities do.

$481M

Proposed borrowing

Repaid over five to seven years

6.9%

Estimated interest rate

On the first $350 million

$232M

Paid in 2025

Settlements and judgments, excluding fees

$82.6M

Budgeted each year

Unchanged since 2020

In 30 seconds

What is proposed

Sell about $481 million in bonds to pay police misconduct settlements and judgments, and repay them over five to seven years.

Why now

Payouts have outrun the budget almost every year. In 2025 the city paid $232 million against $83 million set aside.

What it costs

The Finance Department estimates 6.923% interest on the first $350 million. Last year’s $283 million loan was expected to cost about $52 million in interest.

Where it stands

Watchdogs say borrowing for operating costs breaks basic budget rules. Some alders say it makes sense for a one-time backlog.

Sources: Fox 32 Chicago, Chicago budget hearings begin with questions over head tax, police misconduct costs (Oct. 2026) ↗ · Dunn, Hartwig, Lara and Marlowe, The Public Finance of Police Misconduct Settlements, UChicago Harris Center for Municipal Finance (Aug. 2026) ↗ · Civic Federation, Five things to watch in Chicago’s FY2027 budget: how the mayor’s proposed budget stacks up (Nov. 2026) ↗ · The Bond Buyer, Chicago mayor’s budget plan: pension payments and new revenue (Oct. 2026) ↗

The trend

Payouts have outrun the budget for years

From 2012 through 2025, Chicago paid more than $1.2 billion in police-related settlements. The budget covered the bill in only two of those years.

Paid that yearBudgeted
$39M
$93M
$232M

Settlements and judgments, excluding legal fees. Gold ticks show the amount in the city’s budget. Through the first six months of 2026 the city had already spent at least $225 million, against $82.5 million budgeted.

Sources: Dunn, Hartwig, Lara and Marlowe, The Public Finance of Police Misconduct Settlements, UChicago Harris Center for Municipal Finance (Aug. 2026) ↗ · WTTW News, Chicago has spent at least $225M to resolve police misconduct lawsuits, just six months into the year (2026) ↗

What drives the cost

Where the money goes

Wrongful convictions are now the most expensive category. A small group of officers accounts for much of the rest.

$204.6M

Wrongful convictions, 2025

22 people whose convictions were overturned

$295M

Officers named more than once

272 officers, since 2019 (as of Sept. 2025)

$79.85M

One police chase verdict

Family of a 10-year-old killed after a 2020 chase

$703.6M

Since the consent decree

Police misconduct payouts, 2019 to July 2025

Sources: WTTW News, Wrongful convictions cost Chicago taxpayers $204.6M in 2025 (Dec. 12, 2025) ↗ · WTTW News, Repeated police misconduct by 272 officers has cost Chicago taxpayers $295M since 2019 (Sept. 22, 2025) ↗ · WTTW News, Four months into the year, Chicago set to exhaust $82M budget for police misconduct settlements (Apr. 14, 2025) ↗ · WTTW News, Chicago spent $231.2M to resolve police misconduct lawsuits in seven months (Sept. 2, 2025) ↗

A backlog of old cases

Many of the largest payouts are for wrongful convictions from decades ago, including cases tied to former detective Reynaldo Guevara. Ald. Bill Conway estimates $130 million to $260 million of the new borrowing is for Guevara cases alone.

Source: The Bond Buyer, Chicago mayor’s budget plan: pension payments and new revenue (Oct. 2026) ↗

What borrowing costs

What borrowing costs

Borrowing spreads a big bill over several years, but adds interest. The 2014 settlement bonds will cost almost three times what was borrowed if held to maturity.

BorrowedInterest
  1. 2014 bonds$198 million at 6.314%, if paid to maturity

    $573M
  2. 2026 bonds$283.3 million, five-year repayment (city estimate)

    $335M
  3. 2027 proposal$481 million over five to seven years; interest not yet known

    $481M + interest

Sources: Dunn, Hartwig, Lara and Marlowe, The Public Finance of Police Misconduct Settlements, UChicago Harris Center for Municipal Finance (Aug. 2026) ↗ · Fox 32 Chicago, Chicago budget hearings begin with questions over head tax, police misconduct costs (Oct. 2026) ↗

Other cities

How other big cities pay

The police department pays

Chicago, Las Vegas, Washington, D.C. (larger claims) and Kansas City charge settlements to the police budget.

The city pays from general funds

New York, Los Angeles, Houston, Philadelphia, Dallas and Detroit pay from citywide funds.

A shared risk pool

Phoenix, San Antonio, Indianapolis and Sacramento have the police department pay into a central fund. Some cities also buy excess insurance.

Source: Dunn, Hartwig, Lara and Marlowe, The Public Finance of Police Misconduct Settlements, UChicago Harris Center for Municipal Finance (Aug. 2026) ↗

The debate

The case for, and the case against

The case for borrowing

  1. It buys breathing roomJohnson says borrowing “provides us a little bit of breathing room” while settlement costs soar.
  2. Some cases span many yearsAld. Bill Conway says borrowing makes some sense when the city settles what amounts to several years of costs at once, as with the Guevara cases.
  3. The bills are due either wayJudgments and settlements must be paid; the question is whether this year’s taxpayers cover them all.

The case against

  1. It breaks a basic budget ruleThe Civic Federation says borrowing to pay operating costs violates municipal finance best practices.
  2. Settlements are predictablePayouts vary, but they come every year. Critics say they belong in the regular budget.
  3. It hides the cost of misconductResearchers and budget experts say charging the full cost to the police budget would give the department a reason to reduce claims.
  4. It trades one debt for anotherThe Civic Federation says the borrowing largely cancels out the benefit of the city’s extra pension payment.

Sources: WTTW News, Mayor Johnson again proposes corporate tax hikes to bridge budget gap, says city must borrow (Oct. 20, 2026) ↗ · The Bond Buyer, Chicago mayor’s budget plan: pension payments and new revenue (Oct. 2026) ↗ · Civic Federation, Five things to watch in Chicago’s FY2027 budget: how the mayor’s proposed budget stacks up (Nov. 2026) ↗ · Chicago Tribune via AOL, Mayor Brandon Johnson’s plan to borrow money to pay police settlements raises questions (2025) ↗ · Dunn, Hartwig, Lara and Marlowe, The Public Finance of Police Misconduct Settlements, UChicago Harris Center for Municipal Finance (Aug. 2026) ↗

Proposals

What researchers recommend

A 2026 report from the University of Chicago’s Center for Municipal Finance made six recommendations.

Forecast settlement costs with actuarial methods, so the budget reflects what the city will likely pay.

Modernize the police department’s case and risk-tracking systems.

Cut claims through supervision, early intervention for problem officers and related reforms.

Study central risk pools, premiums tied to each department’s record and excess insurance.

Budget at actual spending levels and stop borrowing to pay settlements.

Publish one report on payments, overruns and how shortfalls are covered.

Source: Dunn, Hartwig, Lara and Marlowe, The Public Finance of Police Misconduct Settlements, UChicago Harris Center for Municipal Finance (Aug. 2026) ↗

Who decides

Who decides

Settles or fights cases

The Law Department

It decides which lawsuits to settle and publishes an annual litigation report. The City Council has never held a hearing on that report.

Source: WTTW News, Repeated police misconduct by 272 officers has cost Chicago taxpayers $295M since 2019 (Sept. 22, 2025) ↗

Changes police practices

The police department and the courts

Since 2019 CPD has been under a federal court order to change how it trains, supervises and disciplines officers.

Source: WTTW News, Chicago spent $231.2M to resolve police misconduct lawsuits in seven months (Sept. 2, 2025) ↗

Ask the candidates

Questions to ask candidates

Should the city borrow to pay police misconduct settlements, or pay them from the yearly budget?

How much should the budget set aside each year for settlements?

Should the cost come out of the police department’s own budget?

How would you reduce the number of misconduct lawsuits?

Should officers with repeated claims face consequences sooner?

Should the Council hold public hearings on the city’s litigation report?

Questions

Common questions

Has Chicago borrowed for settlements before?

Yes. About $100 million in 2011, $198 million as part of a 2014 bond sale and up to $283.3 million authorized in 2026.

Source: Dunn, Hartwig, Lara and Marlowe, The Public Finance of Police Misconduct Settlements, UChicago Harris Center for Municipal Finance (Aug. 2026) ↗

Why not just budget more?

The city has budgeted $82.6 million a year since 2020 even as payouts climbed. Researchers recommend setting the budget at actual spending levels.

Source: Dunn, Hartwig, Lara and Marlowe, The Public Finance of Police Misconduct Settlements, UChicago Harris Center for Municipal Finance (Aug. 2026) ↗

How much will the 2027 police budget set aside?

$90 million for misconduct lawsuits, up from $82.5 million, alongside the proposed borrowing.

Source: WTTW News, Chicago Police Department overspent its budget by $520.5M from 2023 to 2025 (Oct. 2026) ↗

Who pays the interest?

Taxpayers, through future city budgets. Repaying the bonds competes with other city spending for the next five to seven years.

Source: Fox 32 Chicago, Chicago budget hearings begin with questions over head tax, police misconduct costs (Oct. 2026) ↗

Do these numbers include legal fees?

No. The yearly payment figures above exclude fees for outside lawyers, so the full cost is higher.

Source: Dunn, Hartwig, Lara and Marlowe, The Public Finance of Police Misconduct Settlements, UChicago Harris Center for Municipal Finance (Aug. 2026) ↗

Sources

Where these numbers come from

Show all 13 sources

More: 2027 city budget · Public safety · Chicago Police Department by the numbers · Balance the 2027 budget · Mayoral voter match