Issues / 02 Public safety

What reduces violence and builds trust between residents and police?

Homicides surged in 2016 and again in 2020 and 2021, then fell for four straight years. CPD counted 416 murders in 2025, about the same as 2013 and 2014, the lowest years since the mid-1960s, though violence remains concentrated in a small number of neighborhoods.

CommentsUpdated Nov 19, 2026

Updated Nov 19, 2026

Comment

The trend

Homicides, 2005 to 2025

7 measures for this issue · pick one

Lines show United States, New York, Los Angeles, per resident.

Homicides per 100,000 residentsHover over or tap the chart to see each year’s value.
Source: FBI Crime Data Explorer; Chicago from CPD official counts ↗. Per 100,000 residents served by each police department. Chicago uses CPD’s official murder counts (416 in 2025) because its FBI figures break after the FBI’s 2021 reporting change. New York, Los Angeles and Phoenix did not report to the FBI for 2021; those years come from the Major Cities Chiefs Association. The U.S. line is the FBI’s national murder rate.

See how this differs across Chicago →

In this chart · Chicago

Homicides

Homicides per 100,000 residents

Latest (2025)Latest, 2025

15.2

Change since 20241 year

-29%

since 2024

Change sinceChange since

2020

-46%

2015

-11%

2005

-7%

U.S. rank (2025)U.S. rank, 2025

10th of 10

1st = lowestAmong the 10 largest U.S. cities. 1st = lowest

Back to chart ↑

Three things to know

  1. Four years of declineHomicides fell from 805 in 2021 to 416 in 2025, a 48% drop (CPD official counts).
  2. Back to the lows2025 matched 2013 (415) and 2014 (416), the lowest years since the mid-1960s.
  3. Still concentratedViolence remains concentrated in a small number of neighborhoods, so citywide totals hide large local gaps.

In numbers

Public safety in numbers

416

Homicides in 2025 (CPD official count)

Chicago Police Department ↗

−46%

Change since the 2021 peak of 813

City of Chicago Data Portal (CPD) ↗

4 years

Of consecutive decline since 2021

City of Chicago Data Portal (CPD) ↗

59%

Of Chicagoans say there is an area within a mile of home where they would be afraid to walk alone at night (June 2026; 58% in November 2025)

NORC at the University of Chicago, ChicagoSpeaks ↗

The goal

Make every neighborhood safe, with residents who trust the police.

All goals →

Homicides

4162025

2031 goal: 310 homicides · About 11 per 100,000 residents, halfway from today’s rate to the median of the 10 largest cities

▼ Moving the right way Compared with 2024

416

2025

310 homicides

2031 goal

About 11 per 100,000 residents, halfway from today’s rate to the median of the 10 largest cities

▼ Moving the right wayCompared with 2024

Vs U.S. citiesBehind peers · Last of 10

Chicago 15.2

Worst: Chicago 15.2Best: San Diego 1.8

Homicides per 100,000 residents

2025 · FBI Crime Data Explorer; Chicago from the City of Chicago Data Portal ↗ · Goals are Chicago Explainer’s own and are raised when Chicago reaches them.

Ideas for safer neighborhoods

6 ideas, and the case for and against each

Each idea is designed to address the challenges and opportunities Chicago faces on public safety. For each one, you’ll find the strongest arguments for and against it, plus the tradeoff: what you gain, what you give up and who pays. Read both sides, then tell us where you land.

Idea 1 of 6

1Hire and retain more officers

Fill police vacancies and improve retention and training.

Needs a yes fromThe mayor and City Council, through the budget. The department plans about 600 hires in 2027.

What could hold it upRecruiting, the city’s budget gap and rising lawsuit costs. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. More capacity for patrol and investigations
  2. Faster 911 response
  3. Can raise low clearance rates

Against

  1. Expensive and slow to recruit
  2. Does not by itself build trust
  3. Overtime and pensions add long-term cost

The tradeoff

You gain

More capacity for patrol and investigations

You give up

High ongoing cost, including pensions

Who pays

Taxpayers

If nothing changes

Vacancies and overtime stay high, and response times and solve rates depend on a stretched force.

What the evidence says · 1 body of research

Study quality: High Largest scale tested: Many cities

Idea 2 of 6

2Community violence intervention

Fund outreach workers who mediate conflicts and support people at highest risk.

Needs a yes fromThe mayor and City Council for city money, and Springfield, which funds Peacekeepers and other programs.

What could hold it upFederal grant cuts, and disagreement over whether prevention money should come from the police budget. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

No group in the table below opposes it outright on the public record; see where each one stands. Who cares and why ↓

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Reaches people police cannot
  2. Promising evaluations in Chicago
  3. Lower cost per person than incarceration

Against

  1. Results vary widely by program
  2. Hard to measure and scale
  3. Workers face high risk and turnover

The tradeoff

You gain

Reaches the people at highest risk

You give up

Results vary by program; money not spent elsewhere

Who pays

Taxpayers and philanthropy

If nothing changes

Programs funded largely by the state and expiring federal grants could shrink, in the neighborhoods where shootings remain concentrated.

What the evidence says · 3 programs studied

Study quality: Low to High Largest scale tested: Program

Idea 3 of 6

3Non-police crisis response

Send trained responders to mental health calls.

Needs a yes fromThe mayor and the Department of Public Health, which runs CARE teams, plus the City Council’s budget vote.

What could hold it upStaffing, limited overnight hours and an uncertain funding source. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

No group in the table below opposes it outright on the public record; see where each one stands. Who cares and why ↓

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Frees officers for violent crime
  2. Better outcomes for people in crisis
  3. Lowers the risk of use-of-force incidents

Against

  1. Limited hours and coverage so far
  2. Requires new staff and dispatch systems
  3. Some calls turn dangerous

The tradeoff

You gain

Better outcomes for people in crisis; frees officers

You give up

New staff and dispatch costs; some calls turn dangerous

Who pays

Taxpayers

If nothing changes

Police keep handling most mental health calls, and crisis teams stay limited to some neighborhoods and hours.

What the evidence says · 3 programs studied

Study quality: Low to Medium Largest scale tested: Pilot to Citywide

Idea 4 of 6

4Summer jobs for young people at highest risk

Expand One Summer Chicago, which pays teens for summer work with an adult mentor, with more spots for young people most at risk of violence.

Needs a yes fromThe mayor and City Council, through the Department of Family and Support Services budget, plus employers.

What could hold it upThe city’s budget gap and finding enough employers and mentors. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

No group in the table below opposes it outright on the public record; see where each one stands. Who cares and why ↓

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Tested in Chicago with a randomized trial
  2. Reaches young people before violence does
  3. Gives teens income and work experience

Against

  1. Gains were concentrated in violence, not later jobs
  2. Seasonal, and spots are limited by budget
  3. Needs employers and mentors at scale

The tradeoff

You gain

Fewer violent-crime arrests among participants, plus summer income

You give up

Money that could fund year-round programs or policing

Who pays

The city budget, state grants and private employers

If nothing changes

Fewer summer jobs reach the young people at highest risk, in the neighborhoods where youth joblessness is highest.

What the evidence says · 1 body of research

Study quality: High Largest scale tested: Program

Idea 5 of 6

5Solve more shootings

Hire more detectives and civilian investigators, speed up forensic testing and protect witnesses so more shootings and homicides lead to arrests.

Needs a yes fromThe mayor, the police superintendent and City Council through the police budget, and the Illinois State Police, which runs the crime labs CPD uses.

What could hold it upDetective hiring and training, lab backlogs and witnesses’ fear of retaliation. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

No group in the table below opposes it outright on the public record; see where each one stands. Who cares and why ↓

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. Most shootings go unsolved, which can fuel retaliation
  2. Draws support across political lines
  3. Builds trust when cases are solved

Against

  1. Detectives and lab capacity take years to build
  2. Witnesses’ cooperation depends on trust that is hard to rebuild
  3. Adds cost to an already large police budget

The tradeoff

You gain

More cases solved and less retaliation

You give up

Money for patrol or prevention

Who pays

City taxpayers

If nothing changes

Most shootings stay unsolved, which families and researchers link to retaliation and lost trust.

Idea 6 of 6

6Better data for pretrial release decisions

Give Cook County judges an updated, locally tested risk assessment and publish how often decisions follow it, as New York City did with the UChicago Crime Lab, so people unlikely to miss court or be rearrested can await trial at home.

Needs a yes fromThe chief judge of the Cook County Circuit Court, who runs Pretrial Services, and the state’s attorney, who decides when to seek detention. The Illinois Supreme Court and General Assembly set the rules.

What could hold it upDisagreement over how strictly to detain people charged with gun crimes, and skepticism of algorithms. Who decides ↓

Who disagrees, and why

No group in the table below opposes it outright on the public record; see where each one stands. Who cares and why ↓

Your voteOpposeSupport
Comment

For

  1. New York’s research suggests jail use can fall without more crime or missed court dates
  2. Jail is costly for taxpayers and can cost people their jobs and housing
  3. Makes release decisions more consistent from one judge to the next

Against

  1. Judges and prosecutors often set the score aside
  2. Critics worry algorithms carry bias from past arrest data
  3. Victims and police worry about releasing people charged with gun crimes

The tradeoff

You gain

Fewer people jailed who are unlikely to miss court or be rearrested

You give up

Some risk that a released person is charged with a new crime

Who pays

Cook County courts and Pretrial Services, mostly within existing budgets

If nothing changes

The Cook County jail, which passed 6,000 people in 2025, keeps rising and falling with how often prosecutors seek detention and judges grant it.

What the evidence says · 4 studies

Study quality: Low to Medium Largest scale tested: Program to Citywide

Your turn · Reader ideas

What would you do about public safety?

Post your idea in a sentence or two. Readers vote, and each month we review the top ideas and consider them for this page, with the case for and against.

  1. 1 Submit an idea
  2. 2 Vote for the ones you think would work
  3. 3 Each month we review the top ideas
  4. 4 The best are considered for this page
See reader ideas on every issue →

Who decides

Public safety is split between City Hall, Cook County and a federal court

City HallDecides

Runs the police, the budget, violence prevention and crisis teams.

Civilian oversightHas a say

Picks superintendent finalists; COPA investigates misconduct.

Cook CountyDecides

Prosecutes, judges and jails people charged with crimes.

Federal courtOversees

A judge enforces the police consent decree.

Who to ask today

Brandon JohnsonMayor · elected
Fred WallerInterim police superintendent
LaKenya WhiteCOPA chief
Eileen O’Neill BurkeCook County State’s Attorney · elected

Biggest risk nowA new police superintendent will be picked from three finalists about three months before the mayoral election.

See who’s accountable for public safety →

What to watch

Summer violence trends, consent decree progress, staffing levels and clearance rates.

Go deeper

The best pieces on public safety, from different points of view

Who cares and why

The people with a stake, and their point of view

Where each group stands on the ideas above, and the lens it mostly argues from. Every stance links to a public statement, vote or report; a dash means we found no public position.

Lenses GrowthEquityNeighborhoodSafety Stances ● Supports◐ Mixed○ Opposes
WhoTheir point of viewWhat they wantLens Idea 1Hire and retain more officersIdea 2Community violence interventionIdea 3Non-police crisis responseIdea 4Summer jobs for young people at highest riskIdea 5Solve more shootingsIdea 6Better data for pretrial release decisions
Residents of the neighborhoods with the most violence, such as West Garfield Park and Greater Grand Crossing Want both safety and fair treatment from police and other responders. Fewer shootings and respectful, timely help Neighborhood — — SupportsBrighton Park Neighborhood Council backed health-based crisis responseBlock Club Chicago, July 25, 2023 — — —
Police and the Fraternal Order of Police (FOP Lodge 7) Say the department is short of officers and needs staffing, overtime relief and support. More officers and better retention Safety SupportsFOP warned CPD is nearly 2,000 officers shortPolice Magazine, 2023 — — — SupportsFOP contract allowed new homicide team schedules to raise clearancePolice1, 2024 —
Violence prevention groups (Chicago CRED, Metropolitan Peace Initiatives) Say outreach works best with steady funding alongside policing. Sustained, reliable public funding for outreach Safety — SupportsCRED, MPI, CP4P urge city to keep CVI fundingMetropolitan Peace Initiatives, 2025 — — — —
Businesses and downtown (Civic Committee) Care about safety, and the perception of safety, for workers, shoppers and visitors. Lower violence and a downtown people feel safe visiting Growth — SupportsCivic Committee backs expanding violence prevention to most at-risk peopleChicago CRED, 2023 — — — —
Mayor's office and CPD leadership Pair policing with prevention and health responses while holding down police costs. Lower violence within a tight budget Safety MixedCPD to slow hiring and hold 984 positions openChicago Sun-Times, Nov. 5, 2025 — SupportsJohnson expanded CARE crisis teams citywideChicago Sun-Times, May 13, 2026 SupportsJohnson has expanded One Summer Chicago each year as part of his safety planCity of Chicago, March 2025 SupportsCity credits stronger detective work for a 74% homicide clearance rateCity of Chicago, Sept. 2025 —
Progressive and mental health advocates (United Working Families, Treatment Not Trauma) Want money shifted from police vacancies to prevention and mental health care. Funded violence prevention and non-police crisis teams Equity OpposesUWF celebrated cutting unfillable police vacanciesUnited Working Families, Oct. 20, 2025 SupportsUWF credits violence prevention, backs corporate surcharge to fund itUnited Working Families, Oct. 20, 2025 SupportsUWF applauds permanent funding for CARE crisis teamsUnited Working Families, Oct. 20, 2025 — — SupportsCourt watchers faulted judges for jailing many people the tool rated low riskWTTW News, July 30, 2026

The ideas

1 Hire and retain more officers

2 Community violence intervention

3 Non-police crisis response

4 Summer jobs for young people at highest risk

5 Solve more shootings

6 Better data for pretrial release decisions

– means no public position found. Tap a group for details and sources.

Point of view. Want both safety and fair treatment from police and other responders.

What they want. Fewer shootings and respectful, timely help

Idea 3: Supports. Brighton Park Neighborhood Council backed health-based crisis response
Block Club Chicago, July 25, 2023 ↗

Common ground

Most groups want fewer shootings and more trust; they split on how much to spend on police staffing versus outreach and non-police crisis teams.

Help improve this page

This is the initial version. It gets better with your expertise, ideas and experience.

Review this issue

For academics, policy professionals and practitioners. Tell us what is wrong, misleading or missing, and get credited for your review.

Volunteer to review

Share an idea

For anyone with a good idea or lived experience of this issue. Readers vote, and the top ideas are considered for this page each month.

Share an idea

Report an error

Spot a figure that looks wrong? Tell us, with a source if you can. Corrections are dated and explained at the bottom of the page.

Report an error

No comments yet. Be the first to share evidence, experience or a counterpoint.