Explainer · Gunshot detection

Should Chicago bring back gunshot detection?

What ShotSpotter did, what it cost, what the research finds, and where the standoff between the mayor and the City Council stands after voters backed bringing it back.

12

Police districts it covered

About 117 square miles, mostly on the South and West sides

Sept. 22, 2024

Sensors switched off

Mayor Johnson did not renew the contract

72%

Voted to bring it back

Nonbinding advisory referendum, Nov. 3, 2026

43–7

Council vote to force a new contract

Nov. 18, 2026, with a 30-day deadline

In 30 seconds

What it is

Microphones mounted on poles and buildings pick up gunfire, and the system sends police an alert with a location, often before anyone calls 911.

What it cost

About $9 million a year. The 2018 contract was $33 million for three years. Two later budgets set aside $13.9 million for a replacement.

What studies find

They disagree. A new Crime Lab paper’s best estimate is about 49 lives saved a year, but it is not statistically significant. Other studies find slower responses to other 911 calls.

Where it stands

Nine companies bid by April 2025, and no contract has been awarded. On Nov. 18 the City Council gave the city 30 days to award one.

Sources: City of Chicago Office of Inspector General, CPD’s use of ShotSpotter (Aug. 24, 2021) ↗ · Chau, Cook, Lopez, Ludwig, Roemer and Soliman, Policy Evaluation Beyond Significance Testing: Evidence from Chicago’s ShotSpotter Contract, NBER (Nov. 2026) ↗ · Chicago Sun-Times, City Council mandates that city redeploy gunshot detection technology (Nov. 18, 2026) ↗

How it works

From a gunshot to a police alert

ShotSpotter is a product of the company SoundThinking. Chicago’s 2018 contract covered 12 police districts, mostly on the South and West sides, until the sensors were switched off in September 2024.

STEP 1Shots firedOutdoors, within range ofthe sensorsSTEP 2Sensors hear itSeveral microphones pickup the soundSTEP 3Located and checkedSoftware places it;reviewers confirmSTEP 4Alert to policeSent through the city’s911 dispatch centerSTEP 5Officers respondPolice, not paramedics,are sent

It hears shots no one reports

In Washington, D.C., a Brookings study found only about 12% of gunfire picked up by sensors led to a 911 call reporting shots. In Kansas City, alerts came 93 seconds before the first 911 call on average.

Sources: Carr and Doleac, The geography, incidence, and underreporting of gun violence, Brookings (2016) ↗ · Route Fifty, What cities should know about ShotSpotter technology, by Eric Piza (July 2024) ↗

Most alerts found no crime

The inspector general reviewed 41,830 police responses to alerts from January 2020 to May 2021. Officers recorded evidence of a gun crime in 9.1% of them. Supporters say a lack of evidence does not mean no shots were fired.

Source: City of Chicago Office of Inspector General, CPD’s use of ShotSpotter (Aug. 24, 2021) ↗

What the city wants next

The city’s request for a replacement asked for coverage of the whole city and alerts with a location within 60 seconds, at 95% accuracy. ShotSpotter covered 12 districts.

Sources: WTTW News, ShotSpotter replacement requirements and the Justice Project’s first analysis (2025) ↗ · The Hill, ShotSpotter does little to stop gun crime, Chicago watchdog says (Aug. 2021) ↗

How we got here

Eight years, two sides, one stalemate

ContractOversight and shutdownMayor and researchCouncil and voters
  1. Aug. 2018 · Contract

    A $33 million, three-year contract

    Later extended to August 2023 and then into 2024.

    Source: City of Chicago Office of Inspector General, CPD’s use of ShotSpotter (Aug. 24, 2021) ↗

  2. Aug. 2021 · Oversight

    Inspector general questions results

    9.1% of police responses found evidence of a gun crime.

    Source: City of Chicago Office of Inspector General, CPD’s use of ShotSpotter (Aug. 24, 2021) ↗

  3. 2023 · Politics

    Johnson campaigns on ending it

    Ending the contract is one of his campaign promises.

    Source: Chicago Tribune via Yahoo News, Council gives itself power to take control of ShotSpotter, defies Johnson campaign promise (May 2024) ↗

  4. Feb. 2024 · Politics

    Mayor says the contract will end

    He extends it through the Democratic National Convention and later calls it a “walkie-talkie on a stick.”

    Source: Chicago Sun-Times, Mayor Johnson upends gunshot-detection pilot after voters back the technology (Nov. 9, 2026) ↗

  5. May 2024 · Council

    Council votes 34–14 to keep it

    An order calls for a Council vote before removing it from any ward. The mayor calls it illegal.

    Source: WTTW News, City Council votes 34-14 to endorse effort to overturn ShotSpotter decision (May 2024) ↗

  6. Sept. 18, 2024 · Council

    Council votes 33–14; mayor vetoes

    The ordinance would have let the police superintendent sign a contract. One vote short of veto-proof.

    Sources: WTTW News, City Council votes 33-14 to again rebuke Johnson’s decision to scrap ShotSpotter (Sept. 2024) ↗ · ABC7 Chicago, City Council votes to keep ShotSpotter; mayor says he will veto (Sept. 19, 2024) ↗

  1. Sept. 22, 2024 · Shutdown

    Sensors switched off

    The city has had no gunshot detection since.

    Source: CWB Chicago, Study: ShotSpotter may have saved 49 lives a year (Nov. 15, 2026) ↗

  2. April 2025 · Contract

    Nine companies bid on a replacement

    Fifteen responded to an earlier request for information. No contract has been awarded.

    Sources: Chicago Sun-Times, Mayor Johnson upends gunshot-detection pilot after voters back the technology (Nov. 9, 2026) ↗ · Chicago City Wire, Council votes 43-7 to push gunshot detection contract within 30 days (Nov. 18, 2026) ↗

  3. 2025–26 · Research

    Dueling analyses

    A UChicago Justice Project analysis finds no rise in crime after the shutdown; critics question its methods.

    Sources: WTTW News, Steep drop in homicides continued a full year after ShotSpotter was removed (Dec. 29, 2025) ↗ · CWB Chicago, The study excluded gunfire calls (May 28, 2026) ↗

  4. Nov. 3, 2026 · Voters

    72% back bringing it back

    An advisory referendum; 82% voted yes in the 37th Ward.

    Sources: Chicago Sun-Times, Most Chicago voters said they want ShotSpotter back (Nov. 4, 2026) ↗ · Chicago City Wire, Council votes 43-7 to push gunshot detection contract within 30 days (Nov. 18, 2026) ↗

  5. Nov. 2026 · Research

    Crime Lab paper estimates lives saved

    About 49 a year, though the estimate is not statistically significant.

    Source: Chau, Cook, Lopez, Ludwig, Roemer and Soliman, Policy Evaluation Beyond Significance Testing: Evidence from Chicago’s ShotSpotter Contract, NBER (Nov. 2026) ↗

  6. Nov. 18, 2026 · Council

    Council orders a contract within 30 days

    Passed 43–7 after the mayor’s office widened a planned pilot.

    Sources: Chicago Sun-Times, City Council mandates that city redeploy gunshot detection technology (Nov. 18, 2026) ↗ · FOX 32 Chicago, City Council sets 30-day deadline for ShotSpotter replacement (Nov. 18, 2026) ↗

What the research says

What the research says

Researchers agree on some things: alerts reach police before most 911 calls, and most alerts turn up no evidence. They disagree on whether it saves lives or reduces violence, and on whether it pulls officers away from other emergencies.

UChicago Crime Lab and others · Chicago, 2010–2024

Does it save shooting victims’ lives?

Uncertain

Comparing shootings just inside and just outside the coverage zones, the best estimate is that fatality rates were 2.5 percentage points lower, about 49 fewer deaths a year. The result is not statistically significant: there is about a 29% chance of seeing a gap this large by luck alone.

Sources: Chau, Cook, Lopez, Ludwig, Roemer and Soliman, Policy Evaluation Beyond Significance Testing: Evidence from Chicago’s ShotSpotter Contract, NBER (Nov. 2026) ↗ · City Journal, What if we can’t measure ShotSpotter’s impact? (Nov. 2026) ↗

National Institute of Justice study · Chicago and Kansas City

Does it get police to shootings sooner?

Points to a benefit

In Kansas City, alerts came 93 seconds before the first 911 call on average, and officers stopped closer to where shots were fired. The same study found no drop in gunshot victimization.

Source: Route Fifty, What cities should know about ShotSpotter technology, by Eric Piza (July 2024) ↗

Topper and Ferrazares · Chicago, 2016–2022

Does it slow responses to other emergencies?

Points to a cost

As ShotSpotter rolled out by district, police were dispatched to the most urgent 911 calls 23% slower and arrived 13% later, and the chance of an arrest on those calls fell 9%.

Source: Topper and Ferrazares, The Unintended Consequences of Policing Technology: Evidence from ShotSpotter (working paper, 2024) ↗

Journal of Urban Health · 68 large U.S. counties, 1999–2016

Does it reduce gun violence?

No measurable effect

Counties that adopted ShotSpotter saw no significant change in firearm homicides or arrests. The company argues county-wide data dilutes effects in the small areas it covers.

Sources: Doucette and others, Impact of ShotSpotter on Firearm Homicides and Arrests, Journal of Urban Health (2021) ↗ · SoundThinking, response to the Journal of Urban Health study ↗

Chicago Office of Inspector General · 2020–2021

How often do alerts find a crime?

Points to a cost

Officers recorded evidence of a gun crime in 9.1% of responses. Fewer than 2 in 10 stops linked to an alert recovered a gun. The inspector general also found police records too incomplete to judge many alerts.

Source: City of Chicago Office of Inspector General, CPD’s use of ShotSpotter (Aug. 24, 2021) ↗

UChicago Justice Project · Chicago, 2025

Did crime rise after it was switched off?

No measurable effect

No. Homicides in beats that had sensors fell about 32% from Jan. 1 to Sept. 22, 2025, compared with about 28% citywide. That shows crime kept falling, not whether ShotSpotter helped or hurt.

Source: WTTW News, Steep drop in homicides continued a full year after ShotSpotter was removed (Dec. 29, 2025) ↗

Homicides kept falling after the shutdown

Change in homicides, Jan. 1–Sept. 22, 2025, vs. the same period in 2024

Beats that had sensors-32%Citywide-28%

A descriptive comparison, not a test of cause and effect.

Source: WTTW News, Steep drop in homicides continued a full year after ShotSpotter was removed (Dec. 29, 2025) ↗

Was it worth the cost?

Crime Lab estimate of the chance benefits exceeded the roughly $9 million yearly cost

Valuing a life at $500,00070%At the federal $13.6M value~100%

The higher figure assumes the system did no harm. Proving a 2.5-point effect with standard tests would take about 87 years of Chicago data.

Sources: Chau, Cook, Lopez, Ludwig, Roemer and Soliman, Policy Evaluation Beyond Significance Testing: Evidence from Chicago’s ShotSpotter Contract, NBER (Nov. 2026) ↗ · CWB Chicago, Study: ShotSpotter may have saved 49 lives a year (Nov. 15, 2026) ↗

Why studies can’t settle it

Fatal shootings are rare enough, and vary enough from year to year, that a real but modest life-saving effect is very hard to prove. The Crime Lab authors argue the city should weigh the range of likely effects against the cost rather than wait for statistical certainty. Critics of the technology counter that the measurable costs, in officer time and stops, are clearer than the benefits.

Sources: Chau, Cook, Lopez, Ludwig, Roemer and Soliman, Policy Evaluation Beyond Significance Testing: Evidence from Chicago’s ShotSpotter Contract, NBER (Nov. 2026) ↗ · City Journal, What if we can’t measure ShotSpotter’s impact? (Nov. 2026) ↗

The debate

The case for, and the case against

The case for bringing it back

  1. It finds shootings no one reportsMost gunfire is never called in, and alerts reach police before most 911 calls that do come in.
  2. Minutes matter for victimsThe Crime Lab’s best estimate is about 49 lives saved a year. Officers are trained in first aid, including tourniquets, while paramedics are on the way.
  3. It is cheap relative to the stakesAt about $9 million a year, it would pay for itself if it saved one life a year at the federal value of a life.
  4. Voters and many police leaders want it72% voted to bring it back, and 82% in the 37th Ward. Former Supt. Larry Snelling said it helped officers reach victims no one reported.

The case against

  1. Most alerts find no crimeEvidence of a gun crime turned up in 9.1% of responses studied by the inspector general.
  2. It takes officers from other emergenciesOne study found slower responses and fewer arrests on the most urgent 911 calls after it arrived.
  3. No proven drop in gun violenceNational and Chicago studies find no measurable reduction in shootings or homicides, and violence kept falling after the shutdown.
  4. It changes policing in Black and Latino neighborhoodsSensors covered the districts with the highest shares of Black and Latino residents, and the inspector general found alerts shaped when officers made stops.

Sources: Chau, Cook, Lopez, Ludwig, Roemer and Soliman, Policy Evaluation Beyond Significance Testing: Evidence from Chicago’s ShotSpotter Contract, NBER (Nov. 2026) ↗ · CWB Chicago, Study: ShotSpotter may have saved 49 lives a year (Nov. 15, 2026) ↗ · City of Chicago Office of Inspector General, CPD’s use of ShotSpotter (Aug. 24, 2021) ↗ · Topper and Ferrazares, The Unintended Consequences of Policing Technology: Evidence from ShotSpotter (working paper, 2024) ↗ · Doucette and others, Impact of ShotSpotter on Firearm Homicides and Arrests, Journal of Urban Health (2021) ↗ · Chicago Sun-Times, Most Chicago voters said they want ShotSpotter back (Nov. 4, 2026) ↗ · WTTW News, ShotSpotter replacement requirements and the Justice Project’s first analysis (2025) ↗ · The Hill, ShotSpotter does little to stop gun crime, Chicago watchdog says (Aug. 2021) ↗

Who decides

Who decides, and what happens next

Signs contracts

The mayor

The city’s chief procurement officer, who reports to the mayor, awards contracts. Mayor Johnson ended ShotSpotter and has not chosen a replacement. “I support technology, but it has to be technology that is credible,” he said after the referendum.

Source: Chicago Sun-Times, Mayor Johnson upends gunshot-detection pilot after voters back the technology (Nov. 9, 2026) ↗

Sets the budget, passes laws

The City Council

The Council set aside $13.9 million over two budgets and passed the Nov. 18 ordinance. In 2024 the mayor called a similar Council effort illegal and vetoed another.

Sources: Chicago Sun-Times, City Council mandates that city redeploy gunshot detection technology (Nov. 18, 2026) ↗ · WTTW News, City Council votes 33-14 to again rebuke Johnson’s decision to scrap ShotSpotter (Sept. 2024) ↗

Elect the mayor and Council

Voters

The November referendum was advisory. The 2027 city election will decide who carries out, or ignores, the result.

Source: Chicago Sun-Times, Most Chicago voters said they want ShotSpotter back (Nov. 4, 2026) ↗

What happens next

  1. Within 30 days

    Contract deadline

    The ordinance gives the procurement chief 30 days to award a gunshot detection contract.

  2. Within 60 days

    Explain any delay

    If no system is in place, she must explain why in writing and answer questions from the Council.

  3. Pilot

    Six districts, several vendors

    The administration plans a pilot in the Wentworth, Calumet, Englewood, Deering, Ogden and Harrison districts that also tests drones, license plate readers and evidence systems.

Sources: Chicago Sun-Times, City Council mandates that city redeploy gunshot detection technology (Nov. 18, 2026) ↗ · Chicago Sun-Times, Mayor Johnson upends gunshot-detection pilot after voters back the technology (Nov. 9, 2026) ↗

Ask the candidates

Questions to ask candidates

Would you bring back gunshot detection? Which system, and in which neighborhoods?

What results would you require from a vendor, and who would check them in public?

How would you keep alerts from pulling officers away from other 911 emergencies?

Should alerts also send paramedics, not only police?

Would you publish data on every alert and what officers found?

If the evidence stays uncertain, how should the city decide?

See where mayoral candidates stand on gunshot detection in the voter match

Questions

Common questions

Did ShotSpotter send ambulances?

No. Alerts went to police through the city’s dispatch center. Chicago never used it to dispatch paramedics.

Source: WTTW News, ShotSpotter replacement requirements and the Justice Project’s first analysis (2025) ↗

Did shootings go up after it was switched off?

No. Shootings and homicides kept falling in 2025, both citywide and in the areas that had sensors. Because violence fell everywhere, that alone does not show whether the system helped or hurt.

Source: WTTW News, Steep drop in homicides continued a full year after ShotSpotter was removed (Dec. 29, 2025) ↗

Did police respond faster without it?

A UChicago Justice Project analysis found response times to the most urgent 911 calls improved by about 4.2 minutes in beats that had sensors. Critics note it left out shots-fired calls and compared spring and summer with fall and winter.

Sources: UChicago Justice Project, Chicago After ShotSpotter (2026) ↗ · CWB Chicago, The study excluded gunfire calls (May 28, 2026) ↗

Is ShotSpotter the only option?

No. ShotSpotter is SoundThinking’s product. Nine companies bid to replace it, including SoundThinking, and the city has not said which are on its short list.

Source: Chicago Sun-Times, Mayor Johnson upends gunshot-detection pilot after voters back the technology (Nov. 9, 2026) ↗

Was the referendum binding?

No. It was advisory. It showed public opinion but did not require the city to act; the Council’s Nov. 18 ordinance is the attempt to force action.

Sources: Chicago Sun-Times, Most Chicago voters said they want ShotSpotter back (Nov. 4, 2026) ↗ · Chicago Sun-Times, City Council mandates that city redeploy gunshot detection technology (Nov. 18, 2026) ↗

Sources

Where these numbers come from

Show all 24 sources

Working papers from NBER and the UChicago Justice Project analysis had not been peer-reviewed when published. CWB Chicago and City Journal summaries are used only alongside the papers they describe. SoundThinking disputes the inspector general’s and the Justice Project’s findings.

More: All explainers · Public safety · Chicago Police Department by the numbers · Public safety: who’s accountable · Mayoral voter match