Mayors · Overview
How Chicago changed under each of its last four mayors, from Richard M. Daley in 1989 to Brandon Johnson today. We show what each one inherited and handed over, the big decisions and events of each term, and what supporters and critics say. We don’t grade anyone: mayors share credit and blame with national trends, the state and the economy.
Side by side
The last full year before each mayor took office, compared with the last full year in office. For Johnson, the latest year available. Budgets compare the first and last budget each mayor passed, adjusted for inflation. A last row notes what each mayor faced; it is context, not a grade. Terms differ a lot in length, from about three and a half years to 22 years, so compare changes with care. Where a national or big-city figure exists, each cell also shows it for the same years. Each measure’s colored edge shows its issue. Pick an issue to show only its measures, here and in the charts below.
| Measure | Daley1989–2011 | Emanuel2011–2019 | Lightfoot2019–2023 | Johnson2023–present |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| BudgetCorporate Fund budgetfirst vs. last budget passed, 2025 dollarsCity Clerk, budget ordinances ↗ | $3.99B → $4.67B↑ +17% | $4.34B → $4.81B↑ +11% | $5.50B → $5.75B↑ +4% | $5.86B → $6.02B↑ +3% |
BudgetLocal taxes per residentcity tax revenue per resident, 2025 dollarsCity of Chicago annual comprehensive financial reports (Table 3) ↗+ 1 more sourceBLS CPI-U ↗ |
$1,459 → $1,727↑ +18% | $1,727 → $2,400↑ +39% | $2,400 → $2,510↑ +5% | $2,510 → $2,656↑ +6% |
| BudgetBudget deficit per residentprojected Corporate Fund gap per resident, 2025 dollarsCivic Federation, projected deficits since 2008 ↗ | $115 → $346↑ +201% | $328 → $46↓ −86% | $380 → $50↓ −87% | $203 → $421↑ +108% |
BudgetCredit ratingMoody’s, start to endCity of Chicago bond rating analysis ↗+ 1 more sourceThe Bond Buyer ↗ |
A (1992) → Aa3 Start not comparable | Aa3 → Ba1 Downgraded | Ba1 → Baa3 Upgraded | Baa3 → Baa3 No change |
Public safetyMurdersper year, CPD countCity of Chicago Data Portal ↗+ 1 more sourceCPD annual reports ↗ |
660 → 436↓ −34% | 436 → 576↑ +32% | 576 → 719↑ +25% | 719 → 416↓ −42% |
Public safetyMurder rateper 100,000 residentsCPD counts ↗+ 1 more sourceCensus population ↗ |
30.6 → 16.2↓ −14.4 per 100,000U.S.: 9.4 → 4.8 (−49%)Other 9 largest cities, median: 29.0 → 8.0 (−72%) | 16.2 → 21.3↑ +5.1 per 100,000U.S.: 4.8 → 5.1 (+6%)Other 9 largest cities, median: 8.0 → 7.0 (−13%) | 21.3 → 26.8↑ +5.5 per 100,000U.S.: 5.1 → 6.6 (+29%)Other 9 largest cities, median: 7.0 → 13.2 (+91%) | 26.8 → 15.2↓ −11.6 per 100,000U.S.: 6.6 → 4.1 (−38%)Other 9 largest cities, median: 13.2 → 7.5 (−43%) |
| EducationCPS studentsfall enrollmentCPS budget, Appendix A ↗ | 431,750 → 402,681↓ −7% | 402,681 → 361,314↓ −10% | 361,314 → 321,981↓ −11% | 321,981 → 304,687↓ −5% |
| Education4th-grade reading% proficient or above, national test (NAEP)NAEP (Nation’s Report Card) ↗ | 13.8% → 16.1%↑ +2.3 pointsU.S. public: 29.7% → 31.6%Large cities: 19.4% → 22.7% | 17.6% → 26.6%↑ +9.0 pointsU.S. public: 32.4% → 35.4%Large cities: 23.6% → 27.7% | 24.2% → 22.2%↓ −2.0 pointsU.S. public: 34.3% → 32.1%Large cities: 27.3% → 26.1% | 22.2% → 23.3%↑ +1.1 pointsU.S. public: 32.1% → 30.5%Large cities: 26.1% → 26.5% |
| Education8th-grade math% proficient or above, national test (NAEP)NAEP (Nation’s Report Card) ↗ | 9.0% → 15.5%↑ +6.5 pointsU.S. public: 27.3% → 32.5%Large cities: 16.4% → 23.7% | 20.0% → 26.5%↑ +6.5 pointsU.S. public: 33.5% → 33.4%Large cities: 26.0% → 26.8% | 27.2% → 15.8%↓ −11.4 pointsU.S. public: 32.9% → 25.5%Large cities: 27.3% → 20.5% | 15.8% → 20.6%↑ +4.8 pointsU.S. public: 25.5% → 26.9%Large cities: 20.5% → 22.7% |
| EducationGraduation rateCPS five-year cohort rateCPS metrics ↗ | 47.0% → 55.8%↑ +8.8 points | 55.8% → 78.2%↑ +22.4 points | 78.2% → 84.0%↑ +5.8 points | 84.0% → 86.9%↑ +2.9 points |
| EducationFreshmen on track% of 9th graders on track to graduateCPS metrics ↗ | 52.2% → 69.1%↑ +16.9 points | 69.1% → 89.4%↑ +20.3 points | 89.4% → 88.8%↓ −0.6 points | 88.8% → 88.7%↓ −0.1 points |
| EducationAttendanceCPS average daily attendanceCPS metrics ↗ | 90.0% → 91.5%↑ +1.5 points | 91.5% → 92.8%↑ +1.3 points | — → — Not available | 86.9% → 88.4%↑ +1.5 points |
| EconomyUnemploymentmetro area, annual averageBLS via FRED ↗ | 6.4% → 10.5%↑ +4.1 pointsU.S.: 5.6% → 9.6% (+4.0 points)Other 9 largest metros, median: 5.1% → 9.1% | 10.5% → 4.1%↓ −6.4 pointsU.S.: 9.6% → 3.9% (−5.7 points)Other 9 largest metros, median: 9.1% → 4.0% | 4.1% → 4.6%↑ +0.5 pointsU.S.: 3.9% → 3.7% (−0.2 points)Other 9 largest metros, median: 4.0% → 3.6% | 4.6% → 4.7%↑ +0.1 pointsU.S.: 3.7% → 4.3% (+0.6 points)Other 9 largest metros, median: 3.6% → 3.9% |
| TransitCTA ridesboardings per yearCTA annual ridership report ↗ | 605M → 517M↓ −15%U.S. transit, 2000–2010 only: +7% (CTA +8%) | 517M → 468M↓ −9%U.S. transit: −2% | 468M → 244M↓ −48%U.S. transit: −37% | 244M → 319M↑ +31%U.S. transit: +30% |
| PopulationPopulationcity residentsCensus population estimates ↗ | 2.78M → 2.70M↓ −3%U.S.: +24%Other 9 largest cities, median: +19% | 2.70M → 2.70M↑ +0%U.S.: +7%Other 9 largest cities, median: +12% | 2.70M → 2.68M↓ −1%U.S.: +2%Other 9 largest cities, median: −3% | 2.68M → 2.73M↑ +2%U.S.: +3%Other 9 largest cities, median: +3% |
| ContextWhat each mayor facedBig events and inherited costs, not a grade | Leased the Skyway (2005, $1.83 billion) and parking meters (2009, $1.15 billion); most of the money went to general operations and budget gaps. Civic Federation ↗ | Faced rising state-required pension payments; passed a record $588 million property tax increase, mostly for police and fire pensions (2015). CBS Chicago ↗ | The COVID-19 pandemic; about $1.9 billion in federal relief, of which about $1.3 billion went to budget relief through 2023. Bond Buyer ↗ | Arrivals of asylum seekers that began in 2022 (at least 46,282 through 2024; a $639.7 million response); federal pandemic aid nearly spent by early 2025. WTTW News ↗ |
Years compared. Daley: 1988 to 2010, budgets 1990 to 2011 (murder rate 1990 to 2010; population 1990 to 2010; CPS students 1999 to 2010; 4th-grade reading 2003 to 2009; 8th-grade math 2003 to 2009; graduation rate 1999 to 2010; freshmen on track 1997 to 2010; attendance 2008 to 2010; unemployment 1990 to 2010; local taxes 1994 to 2010; deficit budgets 2008 to 2011)Emanuel: 2010 to 2018, budgets 2012 to 2019 (4th-grade reading 2011 to 2017; 8th-grade math 2011 to 2017; attendance 2010 to 2017)Lightfoot: 2018 to 2022, budgets 2020 to 2023 (4th-grade reading 2019 to 2022; 8th-grade math 2019 to 2022)Johnson: 2022 to 2025, budgets 2024 to 2026 (CPS students 2022 to 2026; 4th-grade reading 2022 to 2024; 8th-grade math 2022 to 2024; freshmen on track 2022 to 2023; local taxes 2022 to 2024)
Green means the change moved in the direction most people would call better (fewer murders, lower unemployment, lower taxes, more residents, riders and students, a higher credit rating). Red means the opposite. Yellow means little change: less than 3%, less than 1 point for rates, or less than 2 points for national test scores, which come from samples. Higher local taxes per resident count as worse. Gray means not rated: a bigger or smaller budget is not better or worse on its own. Dollar figures per resident are adjusted for inflation.
Population estimates for 2011–2019 were not revised after the 2020 census, so changes across 2020 overstate gains and losses. Unemployment is for the metro area. “Not available” means the sources we found do not cover those years.
The long view
Where a comparison exists, a dashed line shows the U.S. and a shaded band shows the range of the other nine of the 10 largest cities or metro areas, so you can see which changes were Chicago’s own and which were part of a wider trend.
Peak: 943 in 1992 · Latest: 416 in 2025
CPD official murder counts. Counts for 2012–2015 are not in the CPD reports we found.
Peak: 30.6 in 1990 · Latest: 15.2 in 2025
2025: U.S. 4.1 · median of the other nine largest cities 7.5 · Chicago ranked 10th of 10 (1st = lowest)
Peak: 2.90M in 2000 · Latest: 2.73M in 2025
Census estimates for 2011–2019 were not revised after the 2020 census, which counted more people than they predicted, so changes across 2020 overstate gains and losses.
Peak: 605M in 1988 · Latest: 338M in 2025
2000 to 2025, counted the same way: CTA −33%, U.S. transit −15%
In March 2026 CTA restated 2025 under a new counting method (338M). On the old method, 2025 was 319M, about 3% above 2024.
Peak: 438,589 in 2002 · Latest: 304,687 in 2026
Peak: 26.8% in 2015 · Latest: 23.3% in 2024
2024: U.S. public schools 30.5% · large-city average 26.5%
National Assessment of Educational Progress, Trial Urban District Assessment; tested every two years since 2003 (2021 moved to 2022).
Peak: 27.2% in 2019 · Latest: 20.6% in 2024
2024: U.S. public schools 26.9% · large-city average 22.7%
National Assessment of Educational Progress, Trial Urban District Assessment; tested every two years since 2003 (2021 moved to 2022).
Peak: 86.9% in 2025 · Latest: 86.9% in 2025
CPS changed its method in 2011 (stricter transfer audits) and 2021 (special education graduates counted), so long-run changes are approximate.
Peak: 89.4% in 2018 · Latest: 88.7% in 2023
Five-credit definition, first-time 9th graders, excluding charters. No figures were found for 2019 or 2020; CPS changed the definition in 2024. Under CPS’s stricter 2024 definition (6.5 credits), 84.9% of ninth graders were on track in 2024–25.
Peak: 93.4% in 2016 · Latest: 88.4% in 2025
Figures from 2022 on are CPS’s unadjusted rate and count virtual attendance; 2018–2021 were not published on either basis.
Peak: 10.5% in 2010 · Latest: 4.7% in 2025
2025: U.S. 4.3% · median of the other nine largest metros 3.9% · Chicago ranked 8th of 10 (1st = lowest)
Chicago metro area, not the city alone; city rates usually run higher.
Peak: $6.02B in 2026 · Latest: $6.02B in 2026
Adopted Corporate Fund budgets adjusted for inflation with the U.S. CPI-U; 2025 and 2026 inflation values are estimates.
Peak: $2,706 in 2023 · Latest: $2,656 in 2024
City tax revenue across all governmental funds in the audited annual financial reports, minus the city’s share of state income tax, divided by city population and adjusted for inflation (CPI-U). Includes property taxes, TIF and sales taxes. Population for 1994–1999 is estimated between censuses, and Census estimates for 2001–2009 ran high, so those years read slightly low. No figure was found for 2004. 2025 is left out because Cook County’s late 2025 property tax bills pushed collections into 2026.
Peak: $527 in 2021 · Latest: $421 in 2026
The Corporate Fund gap the city projected before each budget, divided by city population and adjusted for inflation. Every budget passed closed its gap, so this measures the hole each budget had to fill. The earliest gap we found is for 2008; the 2009 figure covers shortfalls in both 2008 and 2009.
About the comparisons. The U.S. murder rate is the FBI’s national estimate (1986–2004 as first published; from 2005, the FBI’s current estimates; 2025 from its August 2026 release). Other cities’ rates are FBI murder and nonnegligent manslaughter counts per 100,000 residents served by each police department, and a city is left out of the band in a year it did not report in full (New York, Los Angeles and Phoenix in 2021; Philadelphia in 2019). Chicago uses CPD’s official counts. Unemployment compares the 10 largest metro areas. Test scores compare U.S. public schools and the average for large cities. The dashed CTA line shows what ridership would have been had CTA changed at the national rate since 2000. Graduation rates are not compared because CPS calculates its rate differently from the national one.
Against the 10 largest
Chicago’s place among the 10 largest U.S. cities for the murder rate, and among the 10 largest metro areas for unemployment, where 1st is the lowest. The years match the side-by-side table.
| Measure | Daley1989–2011 | Emanuel2011–2019 | Lightfoot2019–2023 | Johnson2023–present |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Murder rateamong the 10 largest cities · 1st = lowest | 6th → 9thof 10 · 1990 → 2010 | 9th → 9thof 10 · 2010 → 2018 | 9th → 9thof 10 · 2018 → 2022 | 9th → 10thof 10 · 2022 → 2025 |
| Unemploymentamong the 10 largest metros · 1st = lowest | 9th → 8thof 10 · 1990 → 2010 | 8th → 6thof 10 · 2010 → 2018 | 6th → 9thof 10 · 2018 → 2022 | 9th → 8thof 10 · 2022 → 2025 |
Murder rates: FBI Crime Data Explorer, with CPD’s official counts for Chicago. Unemployment: BLS Local Area Unemployment Statistics.
Borrowing costs
Moody’s rating on Chicago’s general obligation bonds since 2010. Lower ratings mean the city pays more to borrow. Below the dashed line is below investment grade, often called junk.
Earlier, Moody’s rated the city A in 1992. S&P, Fitch and KBRA ratings are on each mayor’s page. Sources: Bond Buyer, Civic Federation, City of Chicago.