Benchmarks · Quality-of-life indexes

How the big city rankings rate Chicago

Four widely quoted indexes each measure something different. Here’s where Chicago lands on each and how it compares with the nine other largest U.S. cities.

Four indexes, four different questions

The rankings disagree mostly because they weigh different things. Indexes built on amenities and reputation favor big, famous metros like Chicago. Indexes that reward low costs favor fast-growing Sun Belt cities.

IndexThe question it answersBuilt forChicago
America's Best CitiesResonance Consultancy, with IpsosWhich metro areas have the most appeal for visitors, talent and investors?Tourism boards, economic developers, real estate investors and companies choosing a location.3rd among U.S. metros3rd of 9 peer metros
Quality of Life IndexNumbeo, a crowdsourced city data websiteWhere does daily life feel best for the money, based on what residents and visitors report?People comparing cities before a move, travelers and journalists. It is free and covers many cities.156.8, 157th of 305 cities7th of 10 peer cities
Quality of Living City RankingMercer (Marsh McLennan)How comfortable would a city be for an employee sent there by a multinational company?Employers and HR teams that set allowances for staff sent abroad.65th of 241 cities in 2023 (tied with Philadelphia); outside the published top 50 in 2024Tied 3rd of 6 peer cities listed
Global Liveability IndexEconomist Intelligence Unit (EIU)How livable is a city for a professional relocating from abroad?Originally built for employers setting hardship allowances; now widely quoted as a general livability ranking.79.2 of 100, 49th of 140 citiesHighest of 4 peer cities listed (2020, latest public full table)

Resonance Consultancy, with Ipsos · 2026 edition, June 2026

America's Best Cities

What it asks

Which metro areas have the most appeal for visitors, talent and investors?

How it is built

Ranks U.S. metro areas on about 29 factors in three groups: Livability (walkability, transit, air quality, climate risk), Lovability (museums, restaurants, nightlife, online reviews and searches) and Prosperity (jobs, education, airport connections, Fortune 500 headquarters). The 2026 edition looked at all 393 metro areas and published a ranked list of the leaders.

Who uses it

Tourism boards, economic developers, real estate investors and companies choosing a location.

Read with care

It rewards big, well-known, heavily visited places, because many inputs count attractions and online buzz. It does not directly measure crime or school quality, ranks whole metro areas (Dallas and Fort Worth share one entry), and its method changes often, so year-to-year moves are only loosely comparable.

See the index ↗

The 10 largest U.S. cities

Lower rank is better

New York
#1
Los Angeles
#2
Chicago
#3
Dallas
#8
Houston
#9
San Diego
#12
Phoenix
#19
Philadelphia
#20
San Antonio
#24

Not shown: Fort Worth (shares the Dallas–Fort Worth metro entry).

Chicago's rank, 2017 to 2026

2017 to 2019 ranked only metros over 1 million people; no U.S. edition was found for 2021.

Numbeo, a crowdsourced city data website · 2026 mid-year edition

Quality of Life Index

What it asks

Where does daily life feel best for the money, based on what residents and visitors report?

How it is built

A fixed formula combines eight scores built from user surveys and price reports: purchasing power, safety, health care and climate push the score up; cost of living, house prices relative to income, commute times and pollution pull it down. The 2026 mid-year table covers 305 cities.

Who uses it

People comparing cities before a move, travelers and journalists. It is free and covers many cities.

Read with care

Inputs come from whoever chooses to answer, with no controlled sample, so small or skewed samples can move a score. Purchasing power carries heavy weight, which favors lower-cost Sun Belt cities with high incomes. The formula changed in December 2017, so earlier scores are not comparable.

See the index ↗

The 10 largest U.S. cities

Higher score is better

Fort Worth
180.8
San Antonio
179.8
San Diego
179.7
Dallas
178.4
Houston
171.1
Philadelphia
160.1
Chicago
156.8
Phoenix
152.9
New York
137.3
Los Angeles
133.3

Chicago's score, 2018 to mid-2026

Two 2026 editions are shown: start of year and mid-year. Chicago's weakest piece is safety (34.9 of 100).

Mercer (Marsh McLennan) · 2023 full table; the 2024 edition (December 2024) published only the top 50

Quality of Living City Ranking

What it asks

How comfortable would a city be for an employee sent there by a multinational company?

How it is built

Rates 39 factors in 10 categories, from political stability, health care and schools to housing, transit, recreation, consumer goods and the natural environment. Cities are scored against New York as the base city. The public 2023 table ranks 241 cities.

Who uses it

Employers and HR teams that set allowances for staff sent abroad.

Read with care

It reflects an expatriate professional’s view, not a typical resident’s. Detailed scores are sold to subscribers, and public editions have been irregular since 2019. The 2024 edition named only its top 50: New York ranked 45th and Los Angeles 44th, and Chicago was not listed. Fast-growing cities such as Phoenix, San Antonio, San Diego and Fort Worth are not in the public table.

See the index ↗

The 10 largest U.S. cities

Lower rank is better

New York
#40
Houston
#62
Chicago
#65
Philadelphia
#65
Los Angeles
#70
Dallas
#73

Not shown: Phoenix (not in the public table), San Antonio (not in the public table), San Diego (not in the public table), Fort Worth (not in the public table).

Chicago's rank, 2008 to 2023

Gaps are years with no public Chicago rank. The number of cities ranked grew over time, which partly explains the drop.

Economist Intelligence Unit (EIU) · 2026 edition, July 2026

Global Liveability Index

What it asks

How livable is a city for a professional relocating from abroad?

How it is built

Analysts score about 30 indicators in five categories: stability (25%), health care (20%), culture and environment (25%), education (10%) and infrastructure (20%). Each city gets a score out of 100. The 2026 edition covers 173 cities, about 21 of them in the U.S.

Who uses it

Originally built for employers setting hardship allowances; now widely quoted as a general livability ranking.

Read with care

Much of the score rests on analysts’ judgment, and the city-by-city table is sold, not published. The free summary names only the top and bottom cities, so Chicago’s 2026 score is not public; the figures here come from the 2020 edition, the latest full table we could find. Scores bunch together, so many cities sit within a point of each other. U.S. cities lose most points on stability (crime and unrest) and health care.

See the index ↗

The 10 largest U.S. cities

Higher score is better

Chicago
79.2
Houston
76.2
Los Angeles
76.0
New York
72.8

Not shown: Phoenix (not in the EIU table), Philadelphia (not in the EIU table), San Antonio (not in the EIU table), San Diego (not in the EIU table), Dallas (not in the EIU table), Fort Worth (not in the EIU table).

EIU publishes only the top U.S. cities for free. New York ranked 66th of 173 in 2026, one of the lowest U.S. scores. Chicago is covered but did not make the U.S. top five.

Honolulu
93.2
Atlanta
92.3
Pittsburgh
92.1
Seattle
91.8
Washington, D.C.
91.2

Bars start at 85 to show the small gaps between cities.

Chicago’s last published category scores

Overall 79.2, 49th of 140, from the last full public table (labeled 2020).

Education
91.7
Infrastructure
92.9
Stability
80.0
Culture and environment
79.2
Health care
58.3

Out of 100. Health care was Chicago’s weakest category. EIU did not publish a normal 2020 edition, so treat the year label with caution.

What the rankings agree on

  1. Chicago scores best on amenitiesResonance, which counts museums, restaurants, nightlife and attractions, puts Chicago 3rd among U.S. metros, behind only New York and Los Angeles.
  2. Safety and cost pull it downNumbeo’s residents rate Chicago’s safety 34.9 of 100, and EIU’s last public scores showed health care and stability as Chicago’s weakest areas. Sun Belt cities with lower costs score higher on Numbeo.
  3. Rank depends on the questionAmong the 10 largest cities, Chicago is 3rd on Resonance, tied 3rd of 6 on Mercer (2023) and 7th of 10 on Numbeo. None of these indexes is a neutral verdict; each reflects its audience.

See Chicago’s own livability measures: arts, sports, walkability, dining and parks →

Sources

Collected November 2026. Numbeo ranks are positions in Numbeo’s score-sorted table, since the site does not print rank numbers. Some past Resonance and Mercer ranks come from press coverage of each edition.